Bond yield curve shifts explained: bear flattening, bull flattening, bear steepening and bull steepening

Wait 5 sec.

The bond yield curve is one of the most useful indicators for understanding how markets are pricing the economic outlook. Rather than looking only at whether Treasury yields are rising or falling, traders also watch how yields move across different maturities. The relationship between short-term and long-term yields can provide clues about expectations for inflation, economic growth and the path of central bank policy.This is where terms such as bear flattening, bull flattening, bear steepening and bull steepening come in. The terminology can sound complicated, but it is actually quite straightforward once you separate two questions:Are bond prices rising or falling?Is the curve becoming flatter or steeper?"Bear" means bond prices are falling which is reflected in rising bond yields, while "bull" means bond prices are rising which is reflected in falling bond yields. "Flattening" means the difference between long-term and short-term yields is narrowing, while "steepening" means that difference is widening.The basicsThe yield curve plots government bond yields across different maturities, from short-term bills to longer-term bonds. A commonly watched measure is the spread between the 10-year and 2-year Treasury yields.For example:2-year yield: 4.00%10-year yield: 4.50%10s2s spread: +50 basis pointsIf the 2-year rises to 4.30% while the 10-year rises to 4.60%, the spread narrows from 50 to 30 basis points. That is a flattening. If instead the 2-year falls to 3.70% while the 10-year falls to 4.30%, the spread widens from 50 to 60 basis points. That is a steepening. The key is that the curve can change shape even when both yields are moving in the same direction.Bear FlatteningA bear flattening occurs when bond prices fall and yields rise, but short-term yields rise more than long-term yields.For example:2-year: 4.00% → 4.50%10-year: 4.50% → 4.70%Both yields increased, meaning the bond market experienced a bearish move. But the 2-year yield rose by more, causing the curve to flatten. Bear flattening is often associated with expectations for tighter monetary policy.If markets believe the central bank will increase or keep interest rates higher for longer, short-dated bonds can sell off aggressively because their yields are closely linked to expectations for policy rates.The long term yields can also rise, but if investors believe tighter monetary policy will eventually slow the economy and inflation, long-term yields may not rise as much as short-term yields.We had a major bear flattening in 2022 when the Fed raised rates aggressively to fight inflation. Short-end yields rose much faster than long-end yields which were looking for signs of economic slowdown caused by the aggressive tightening.Bull FlatteningA bull flattening occurs when bond prices rise and yields fall, but long-term yields fall more than short-term yields.For example:2-year: 4.00% → 3.80%10-year: 4.50% → 4.00%Both yields fall, but the larger decline in the 10-year yield causes the curve to flatten. Bull flattening can occur when investors become more concerned about long-term economic growth or when long-term inflation expectations decline. It can also happen when investors seek the safety of longer-duration government bonds.Bull flattening does not necessarily mean the central bank is becoming more dovish. The front end can remain relatively anchored by expectations that policy rates will stay elevated, while the long end falls because investors become more concerned about the economy further ahead.We had a bull flattening in 2016 when rates were already at 0% and there was weak growth. Long-end yields fell more than short rates which were already at 0%.Bear SteepeningA bear steepening occurs when bond prices fall and yields rise, but long-term yields rise more than short-term yields.For example:2-year: 4.00% → 4.20%10-year: 4.50% → 5.00%Both yields rise, but the 10-year yield increases more, causing the curve to steepen. Bear steepening is often associated with rising long-term inflation, growth or fiscal risk. The central bank may not be expected to raise short-term rates significantly, but investors demand a higher yield to hold longer-dated bondsThe important distinction is that the source of the move is often further out the curve, rather than an aggressive repricing of immediate central-bank policy. Bear steepening can therefore occur when markets are worried about longer-term inflation or fiscal risk. Importantly, expectations of robust economic activity can also prompt markets to price in higher long-term risk premiums.We had a major bear steepening in 2024 on strengthening growth expectations and higher inflation risks due to Fed rate cuts, AI spending and higher Trump victory odds. Long-end yields rose faster than short-end yields.Bull SteepeningA bull steepening occurs when bond prices rise and yields fall, but short-term yields fall more than long-term yields.For example:2-year: 4.00% → 3.30%10-year: 4.50% → 4.20%Both yields decline, but the larger move at the front end causes the curve to steepen. Bull steepening is often associated with expectations that the central bank will cut interest rates. The long end may also decline, but potentially by less because long-term yields incorporate more than just the expected policy rate.Bull steepening is often associated with a transition toward easier monetary policy. But the reason behind the steepening matters. A bull steepener caused by expectations of a benign normalization in rates is different from one caused by a sudden recession shock. In the latter case, markets may aggressively price central bank cuts which causes short-term yields to fall faster than long-term ones.We had a major bull steepening in 2020 due to the COVID shock and aggressive Fed easing. Front end yields collapsed toward zero.Why the Shape Matters for MarketsThe yield curve is important because different parts of the curve respond to different forces. The front end is heavily influenced by expectations for central bank policy. The long end is influenced by a broader combination of inflation and growth expectations, fiscal policy, term premium and future short-term interest rates. That means that a headline saying "Treasury yields rose" can have completely different implications. Let's say for example, we have a hawkish Fed repricing. The 2-year yield jumps 20 bps while the 10-year rises only 5 bps. That's a bear flattening. The market is primarily repricing the expected path of monetary policy. On the other hand, let's say the market starts to expect stronger growth ahead. The 2-year yield rises 5 bps while the 10-year jumps 20 bps. That's a bear steepening. The market is placing more of the risk in the longer-term inflation given the growth expectations.The headline is the same "Treasury yields rose", but the message from the curve is differentKeep in mind that a yield curve shift is a market signal, not a guaranteed economic forecast. The same curve move can have different interpretations depending on what is happening. So context is key. This article was written by Giuseppe Dellamotta at investinglive.com.