In hindsight, it feels like Ken Jennings was always the natural choice to succeed Alex Trebek as the host of Jeopardy!, but those who can recall the dark days of 2021 remember that wasn’t exactly the case. Sony Pictures had lots of other options, and it was quite an eventful road before Jennings emerged as the quiz show’s one true host. It’s a good thing that his wife wasn’t in charge of the decision, though, because he recently revealed that Mindy Jennings preferred a different man behind the lectern.Ken Jennings is one of Jeopardy’s biggest winners and the undisputed GOAT champion. He was even the first guest host to take the reins when Alex Trebek passed away in November 2020. However, rather than name Jennings — or anyone — Trebek’s permanent replacement, Jeopardy! decided to bring in a bevy of guest hosts, and that’s where Mindy Jennings found her favorite — none other than NFL quarterback Aaron Rodgers. As the now-host told People:He was a solid guest host. He was my wife’s favorite, actually. When I tried to figure out why, I was like, ‘Honey, you know I was a guest host, too.’ And she was like, ‘Well, he’s very handsome.’It sounds like Mindy Jennings is just as funny as Ken! And I mean, you can’t really be mad at her for picking Aaron Rodgers as her favorite Jeopardy! guest host. For one thing, the Pittsburgh Steelers QB prepped really hard for the role, and secondly, it turns out there’s one pretty annoying side effect to your husband being the host of Jeopardy! Lastly, and possibly most importantly, she’s right that he was pretty easy on the eyes:(Image credit: Sony Pictures)There was actually a point in time when Aaron Rodgers said he was interested in hosting Jeopardy! full time, but alas, the call of the football field was too strong. That ended up working out well for Ken Jennings — if not Mindy — even though he still had to endure the Mayim Bialik co-hosting era (and don’t even get me started on the Mike Richards fiasco).Ken Jennings’ wife isn’t the only one who had a favorite guest host back in the day. Matt Amodio played under a whopping seven different hosts during his 38-game win streak — Ken Jennings, Mayim Bialik, Mike Richards, Joe Buck, Robin Roberts, LeVar Burton and David Faber. He named Buck as the one he’d call back up, so I guess we can assume he tuned into ESPN Jeopardy! with his Hulu subscription this summer.Jeopardy!’s guest host era was interesting, to say the least, and while I respect Mindy Jennings’ choice, I have to say I’m happy to see Ken consistently killing it in the role. So you’d be right to assume that I’m counting down the hours until Jeopardy! Masters Season 4 hits the 2026 TV schedule. Tune in at 8 p.m. ET Tuesday, August 25, on ABC for the two-week event that promises to be fun, despite its pronounced lack of hunky NFL stars.