Goldman flags China stimulus risk as growth slips further below target

Wait 5 sec.

A confirmed slowdown toward the 4% handle keeps pressure on Chinese equities and the yuan, particularly if incoming August and September data fail to show stabilisation. The gap between bank estimates, Goldman at the softer end near 4%, Macquarie near 4.2%, BNP Paribas at 4.1%, points to genuine uncertainty over how much fiscal and monetary support Beijing will ultimately deploy, which should keep policy-sensitive Asian equities and industrial commodities reactive to each fresh data point. Markets are likely to treat a reserve requirement ratio cut in the fourth quarter as the base case rather than a policy rate cut, given the PBOC's reluctance to touch benchmark rates amid lingering trade war pressure and firmer factory-gate inflation from higher oil prices. Any signal from Beijing that moves beyond incremental support, particularly around consumption rather than supply-side manufacturing measures, would likely be read as a more durable positive catalyst for Chinese domestic demand plays than the current policy mix suggests.---Goldman Sachs note via a weekend Bloomberg (gated) report. ---China's growth is sliding toward 4%, and while easing bets are climbing, Beijing still looks more inclined to tinker than to stimulate hard.Summary:Goldman Sachs estimates China's GDP growth slowed to about 4% year-on-year early in the third quarter, down from 4.3% in the prior quarter, with the deceleration described as demand-driven.Macquarie estimates July data implies monthly growth of about 4.2%, while BNP Paribas puts the figure at 4.1%, both below the pace needed to hit Beijing's 4.5 to 5% annual target.BNP Paribas expects fresh stimulus in late September or early October if growth stays at or below 4% through August and September.The PBOC is expected to hold its policy rate steady through 2026 and 2027, according to a Bloomberg analyst poll, with a reserve requirement ratio cut seen as more likely in the fourth quarter.Premier Li Qiang has called on the government to ramp up supportive measures, and officials are considering loan subsidies and other financing support for businesses and consumers.State media has defended China's economic performance, emphasising the quality of technological innovation and industrial development over headline growth rates, while Goldman warns this focus is unlikely to boost incomes or consumption.China's economic growth slipped further below Beijing's annual target in the early weeks of the third quarter, according to Goldman Sachs, reviving expectations that policymakers will need to step up monetary easing even as officials have so far only floated incremental measures. Goldman's chief China economist, Hui Shan, estimated in a report that gross domestic product growth was running at about 4% year-on-year early this quarter, down from 4.3% in the prior three months, with July's weakness in industrial output, consumption and investment attributed to softening demand rather than supply constraints.Hui described the deceleration as more concerning than an earlier slowdown in April because it started from a lower base and hit sectors that had previously appeared resilient. She said conversations with traders and investors point to rising market expectations for monetary policy easing. Goldman's assessment sits among the more downbeat of global banks following official data that showed a broad-based slowdown last month. Macquarie Group estimated July data implied monthly GDP growth of about 4.2%, while BNP Paribas put the figure at 4.1%, roughly 0.2 percentage points below the pace needed in the second half to meet China's full-year target. BNP Paribas economists led by Jacqueline Rong said that if growth continues to hover at or below 4% through August and September even with greater fiscal effort, the annual target would be at risk, and that policymakers would likely respond with fresh stimulus in late September or early October.Before this latest deterioration, several economists had already been walking back calls for a rate cut this year after higher oil prices pushed up factory-gate inflation. A Bloomberg poll of analysts conducted in July put the median expectation at an unchanged PBOC policy rate through this year and next, with a cut to banks' reserve requirement ratio seen as the more likely tool, potentially arriving in the fourth quarter. The PBOC has not cut either its benchmark rate or the RRR in more than a year, a period that coincided with the height of trade tensions with the US.Despite rising pressure to act, Chinese officials have so far signalled little urgency for bolder stimulus. Premier Li Qiang told a cabinet meeting on August 17 that the government should ramp up supportive measures to meet annual development targets, and officials have since said they are considering loan subsidies and other financing support for businesses and consumers. State media has meanwhile pushed back on concerns over the headline growth number. A People's Daily commentary on August 22 argued that policymakers should not fixate solely on the growth rate or short-term indicators, instead emphasising the quality of technological innovation and the sustainability of growth. A separate commentary published under the same byline the following day described China as the main engine of the world economy and a stabilising anchor for global supply chains, framing the economy as resilient despite external pressure.Goldman's Hui cautioned that Beijing's continued emphasis on technological innovation and high-tech manufacturing is unlikely on its own to lift incomes or consumption meaningfully, since manufacturing accounts for only about a fifth of Chinese employment. She said upcoming measures may help the government hit this year's growth target but remain largely supply-driven, meaning they are unlikely to generate the kind of durable demand momentum needed to shift the underlying growth trajectory.  This article was written by Eamonn Sheridan at investinglive.com.