Manchester United suffered a 1-0 defeat at home to Manchester City despite being up against ten men for much of the game.Phil Foden saw red in the 23rd minute at Old Trafford, but Man Utd never really looked like taking advantage with a tame performance throughout.There was some controversy about Erling Haaland’s winning goal for Man City, with the Norway international arguably looking offside when the ball was played across goal.Still, there’s also no doubt that United were poor and wouldn’t have been deserving winners on the day.Here’s a look at how their players rated in today’s defeat against City…Manchester United player ratings vs Manchester CitySenne Lammens – 6 – Couldn’t keep a clean sheet despite City failing to actually create that many clear-cut chances, with the goalkeeper conceding one of only two shots on target he faced.Diogo Dalot – 6.5 – Solid if unspectacular on the right-hand side, largely keeping City left-winger Antoine Semenyo quiet for much of the game.Patrick Dorgu – 6.5 – Dangerous going forwards, even if it didn’t quite come off for him today.More Stories / Latest NewsMan United player ratings: Summer signing fails to stamp authority against 10-man CitySep 13 2026, 18:57“I have to say…” – Two Man United legends are saying the same thing about controversial City goalSep 13 2026, 18:09Fabrizio Romano reveals one Man Utd transfer was “very advanced” until Michael Carrick interventionSep 13 2026, 17:52Harry Maguire – 6.5 – Not a lot wrong in a generally steady performance, but not quite enough to snuff out the threat of Haaland.Lisandro Martinez – 6.5 – Made three tackles as he did his best to fight off City’s attack.Youri Tielemans – 5.5 – Despite looking like a promising signing when he joined this summer, Youri Tielemans looked like the weak link in midfield, with Enzo Fernandez comfortably winning that battle.Youri Tielemans in action for Manchester United (Photo by Michael Regan/Getty Images)Kobbie Mainoo – 7 – A bright spark in midfield for United, Kobbie Mainoo also hit the woodwork with a great strike.Bruno Fernandes – 6.5 – Not at his influential best today, and somewhat fortunate not to also get punished for that Foden incident.Bryan Mbeumo – 6 – Didn’t provide enough of a threat, and could arguably have done better to track back as Josko Gvardiol got forward from left-back to set up the Haaland winner.Marcus Rashford – 6.5 – Hit the woodwork and probably had the best game out of the MUFC front three, even if it wasn’t enough to make a meaningful difference.Matheus Cunha – 6 – Just three shots, and none on target, it was an underwhelming display from Matheus Cunha as United’s main striker.Subs: Benjamin Sesko (6), Joshua Zirkzee (6)Want more CaughtOffside coverage? Add us as a preferred source on Google to your favourites list for news you can trustThe post Man United player ratings: Summer signing fails to stamp authority against 10-man City appeared first on CaughtOffside.