We saw that in Goblet of Fire, Bertha Jorkins was able to remember some things that Crouch made her forget with his memory charm because Voldemort tortured her so much that she was able to remember. Taking this line of thought, if someone had a really bad memory accident happen to them, similar to what happened to Lockhart, and they really wanted their memory back, would voluntarily getting tortured allow themselves to regain their memory?   submitted by   /u/FlatwormUnfair7326   to   r/harrypotter [link]   [comments]