"They have no possible sensitivity in regard to the pollution and how hazardous it is... the AQI at a particular point of time during the Diwali festival was at the highest. We want to prevent this," the judge added, referring to the Air Quality Index. (File)Expressing displeasure over poor air quality during Diwali and the “insensitivity” of people bursting firecrackers beyond the rules and permissible time limits, the Bombay High Court (HC) on Thursday said it was considering a “drastic order” imposing a complete ban on firecrackers, except for community displays on permissible grounds, similar to those in other countries.After concluding the hearing of the petitioners, the state government, civic authorities and intervenors, including firecracker dealers and activists, a bench of Justices Girish S Kulkarni and Neela K Gokhale reserved its order on a suo motu public interest litigation (PIL) and other pleas raising concerns over noise pollution and the bursting of firecrackers on public streets during festivities.Last month, the bench had directed that the “total ban” on bursting firecrackers on public streets and roads during festivities would apply throughout the year.The HC said that while its orders did not pertain to any particular festival or season, they appeared to have been “selectively understood” by some people who had “no consciousness for the societal cause”. It also said the Brihanmumbai Municipal Corporation’s (BMC) decision to ban aerial firecrackers during Diwali was “very important”.“Because it is really causing problems to the properties of people. There were 332 fires in the city. If it is the correct figure which is actually being reflected in the news reports, then it is alarming,” Justice Kulkarni orally remarked.“They have no possible sensitivity in regard to the pollution and how hazardous it is… the AQI at a particular point of time during the Diwali festival was at the highest. We want to prevent this,” the judge added, referring to the Air Quality Index.“We’ll have to take some drastic orders now, really, in the larger interest of lakhs of citizens of this city. And unless we have this kind of proactive approach, nothing is going to improve. Because people are not going to change their mindset and we are still going to have all these firecrackers and there would be tremendous noise pollution even up to 3 am. What is this? The police and municipal machinery were totally helpless. They did their best, but it was totally beyond their control,” the bench said.Story continues below this adThe judges said the court would have to “nip it (toxicity) in the bud” and that “the only thing would be to ban all these firecrackers in the city of Mumbai”. They added, “There would be only community firecrackers and on permissible grounds where only it would be like in the other countries, which is kind of a fire show with no pollution—only community firecrackers to be used. It is the only solution so that you are relieved of toxicity in the city.”The HC reiterated that the “social fabric and great quality of Mumbai was togetherness”, irrespective of communities, and said the present situation with respect to pollution “was not good”.Senior advocate Sanjeev Gorwadkar, appearing for Thane PIL petitioner Dr Mahesh Bedekar, and amicus curiae Anand Pai sought a complete ban on firecrackers, arguing that citizens’ health was “absolutely paramount”. The petitioner claimed that laboratory findings showed most “green crackers” carried fake QR codes and contained banned chemicals. The HC remarked that life-threatening practices were not entitled to protection under Article 25 of the Constitution, which guarantees all persons freedom of conscience and the right to freely profess, practise and propagate religion.The authorities claimed they had made sufficient efforts to implement the court’s orders. They said the Mumbai Police had registered 491 cases and seized firecrackers worth Rs 21 lakh between November 4 and 13. The HC said it would consider passing an order applicable across the state.Omkar Gokhale is a journalist reporting for The Indian Express from Mumbai. His work demonstrates ex... Read More Tags:Mumbai