6 min readNov 20, 2026 06:20 AM IST First published on: Nov 20, 2026 at 06:20 AM ISTWhen we write the story of India’s development, the last couple of decades may well come to be described as India’s Great Stagnation. But India’s Great Stagnation is not economic. The economy has grown. The Great Stagnation is in the capacity of the Indian state. So much excellent contemporary work has documented this fact in staggering detail, from Devesh Kapur’s pioneering work on state capacity to the work of the two most storied bureaucrats currently in government, T V Somanathan and Gulzar Natarajan.The broad facts are clear. The Indian state, in headcounts, is extremely small, especially if you remove the railways. As Arvind Subramanian and Kapur noted in A Sixth of Humanity, total public employment peaked at 3.84 per cent in 1981 and is currently just above 2 per cent, the lowest in Asia. All of this while the size of the economy and the mandate of the state grew. In terms of judges, famously, we have only 1.1 per hundred thousand of the population. Second, the Indian state is hugely malapportioned. In most successful countries like China and the US, two-thirds of government employees work for local government, five times more than in India. Local government, where most of development is delivered, is very weak.AdvertisementJust to pick a random state, the total number of municipal employees paid by the state in Andhra Pradesh is just 26,000; the total in all Gram Sachivalayas is only 82,000. The Sachiv ji of the series Panchayat is truly a lonely and forlorn figure. The addition of contractual labour does not compensate for small numbers. Third, there is a chronic shortage of recruitment even against vacant posts; the shortage gets worse the lower the tier of government. According to a recent survey, Gurugram, from where I am writing this, has a 27 per cent shortfall in the district commissioner’s office; in many states, this routinely rises to 40 per cent. And fourth, other than the contractualisation of some services, there has been no radical rethinking of the kind of personnel or recruitment strategies we want in the state. Simply put, the Indian state does not have a serious HR policy.These facts are well known. Their consequences are also well known. First, scarcity of personnel itself creates forms of discretionary power and rents. Even when there are no rents, selective enforcement creates appearances of injustice. Tukaram Mundhe is being accused of selective enforcement, when the brute fact is that the number of food safety officers needed for consistent enforcement across all eateries in Maharashtra would require at least triple the strength of the current staff. Third, as Aditya Dasgupta and Devesh Kapur’s paper, “The Political Economy of Bureaucratic Overload”, demonstrated, officials with fewer resources are worse at implementing programmes. One bureaucrat once joked that all state governments in India have the capacity to do about two and a half schemes well; the only question is which are the schemes to which they allocate scarce personnel and governance resources. The new PRS State of State Finances report chronicles how much states are still underspending: We do not even have capacity to spend. For every success in a state government, you will pay a hidden cost for something important that remains undone. Fourth, this scarcity of personnel skews the architectural choice of development. I suspect the mania for cash transfers is as much a reflection of the incapacity of the state to do things as it is driven by electoral largesse. The lack of state capacity reflects on national credibility and potentially legitimacy.Indian stagnation seems to be overdetermined: Certainly, there is an ideological element. After liberalisation, we thought there were gains to reducing government functions and increasing its efficiency. But the move to markets does not necessarily reduce the demands on the state; it changes the character of the risks and externalities we need to manage. In any case, so many core functions of the state cannot be wished away. Even efficiency and technology, and doing away with frivolous functions, presuppose a critical minimum mass to work with. But that naïve ideological picture of liberalisation came in the way of thinking about the state. Because so much state power is discretionary, we fear more state personnel. Another ideological element is centralisation; there is still an unconscionable neglect of local government where most development happens.AdvertisementSomanathan, Natarajan and Karthik Muralidharan had another explanation: State wages are considerably higher than those in the private sector by orders of magnitude. So, the government accepts low staffing and higher wages. The public would also accept the opportunity to compete to enter a relatively small aristocracy rather than increasing the number of government jobs.you may likeIndian politicians are, by instinct, fiscally conservative. They achieve their goals by keeping the state small, so they can spend on schemes. We also often run fiscal policy through vacancies in recruitment. Part of the explanation for chronic vacancies is that this is a covert way to rein in expenditure. But this produces the worst of all worlds, since it makes serious HR planning impossible. Most people in government also find the prospect of dealing with a larger number of organised government employees politically fraught. To keep the organised power of government employees limited, we are willing to keep the state less capable. But there is a final irony in all this. There have been abortive attempts to do two things. The first is that every scheme, regulation, and function of the state must have some administrative assessment attached to it. The second is a serious HR strategy for the state, including the design of exams and recruitment processes. The irony is that the Indian state does not have the personnel and capacity to do this.The fact that we have come to see proper expenditure on the state as an expenditure and not an investment is a manifestation of the crisis of the state. In all the talk of reforms, no political formation has thought of how we can escape the Great Stagnation that is the Indian state.The writer is contributing editor, The Indian Express