Supreme Court grants interim custody of 4-year-old boy to German mother

Wait 5 sec.

The Supreme Court on Thursday granted interim custody of the four-year-old boy of an unmarried couple to his German mother and allowed her to take him to Singapore for studies, rejecting the father’s claim that uprooting the child from his familiar environment in India will be greatly distressing to him.A bench of Justices NK Singh and NV Anjaria said “the mother has a better prima facie claim of custody over the child” and “the balance of convenience lies in favour of the mother”.“It is most likely that the child may suffer irreparable injury in the event the interim custody is not given to the mother, as the mother has a better/more concrete plan for his education and well-being in the interim, which is in the child’s best interests,” the bench added.The SC clarified that the arrangement is interim till the guardianship petition filed by the father is decided by the Patiala House Court here.The mother is a German citizen who ordinarily lives and works in a senior position with TikTok in Singapore while the father is a lawyer who runs a law firm in New Delhi. Their relationship started in 2019, and the child was born in 2022 in New Delhi. They never married.During their years together, the family lived in Delhi, Goa and Singapore, but differences cropped up gradually and they approached reached courts, including the Supreme Court.On August 11, 2026, the SC sought a report by the National Institute of Mental Health and Neurosciences (NIMHANS) to understand the child’s psychological and mental conditions.Story continues below this adThe SC said, “From our observations during interactions with the parents and child, as well as from the NIMHANS Report, both parents are equally invested in the child’s well-being. There is nothing to show that either parent cannot provide the warmth, compassion, care and guidance such a tender-aged child requires.”It added, “However, the Report also mentions that the child is fluent in English and German, which indicates a close bond with the mother in her mother tongue/native language. In that circumstance, if interim custody is granted to the father, it is not only that the mother will be deprived of the company of the child, but that the child will be deprived of her love and company during a critical developmental period of his life.”The judgment said, “Child psychology acknowledges that the company of the mother, and maternal care and attention, is most desirable for a very young child if the bonding between mother and child has remained intact…The NIMHANS Report clearly shows that the mother and child have a very good and strong bond, that the child is very comfortable with the mother, and that the mother does not have diagnosable issues that would prevent her from being less caringtowards the child than the father.”Appearing for the father, Senior Advocate Gopal Sankaranaryanan contended that uprooting the child from his familiar environment in India will be greatly distressing and may cause irreparable harm to the mental state of the child. He argued that the established roots of the child are in India and allowing the mother to take the child to Singapore would amount to dislocation of the child.Story continues below this adThe SC, however, said “Whether the child has already been rooted in the Indian environment is a matter of fact to be established” and “the NIMHANS Report clearly indicates that the child is comfortable with both/either of the parents. Accordingly, the father’s concern that the child would be uprooted from familiar surroundings in India if the child is relocated to Singapore appears to be an overstatement.”On father’s argument that the mother’s professional commitments have limited her parenting time in the past and will continue to leave her with insufficient time for the child, the court said, “We find that although she is working in a senior role at a large company, we cannot hold her professional commitments against her, as she has provided us with her employer’s Work-from-Home policy and their endorsement of the same, which clearly supports her ability to adjust her working hours to be present for the child when he is not in school.”It added that though the father is also capable of providing a high quality of life and education for the child, “we are concerned with certain other aspects which appear to be against the father. The father is admittedly a successful lawyer running a busy law firm in Delhi, employing about 53 associates. The father has a wide professional network, practising law not only in Delhi but also in other places such as Goa, Mumbai, and Bengaluru.“We are well aware of the limited time a busy lawyer can spare for family members. In the present case, the family member is not an adult, but a small child of four years who is very energetic, as the NIMHANS Report also shows, who will require much more personal attention. The demands of a small child of this age can be very unpredictable, and we are not very confident that the father would be in a position to spare sufficient and adequate time for the child during the most crucial period for his development… .”