14% Weekly Drop to a New 52-Week Low: Is the Selling Overdone?

Wait 5 sec.

14% Weekly Drop to a New 52-Week Low: Is the Selling Overdone?NIO Inc. Sponsored ADR Class ABATS:NIOKalaGhaziNIO shares fell 14% over the course of a week and touched a new 52-week low, even though there was no major company-specific news behind the move. The decline was not isolated: XPeng and Li Auto also weakened, while the broader market moved higher. That pattern suggests investors were selling electric-vehicle names as a group rather than reacting to a single NIO announcement. The more important trigger appears to be NIO’s October delivery report, which has raised doubts about whether the company can deliver a strong fourth quarter. NIO delivered 34,246 vehicles in October, down 15.2% from 40,397 a year earlier and below September’s 37,408. The entire year-over-year decline came from ONVO, NIO’s family brand: ONVO deliveries dropped 51.7% to 8,383, while the NIO brand itself rose 5.7%. That split matters because it shows the weakness was concentrated in the newer brand rather than in NIO’s core brand. On its Sept. 1 earnings call, management set a target of more than 40,000 deliveries per month in the current quarter, a goal tied to an expected recovery in China’s car market. To reach that target now, NIO would need about 43,000 deliveries in each of November and December. That is a demanding pace, and October’s softness has given investors a concrete reason to question the fourth-quarter outlook. The selling does not yet look clearly overdone. NIO has looked cheap for months, and October provided a real reason for investors to doubt the fourth quarter. The forward price/sales multiple is now at a five-year low, but a low multiple alone does not prove a bottom. The third-quarter report needs to show vehicle margin holding near 18.5% before the current share price can be viewed as too low. If vehicle margin holds near that level, the stock may look undervalued. If margin slips, however, the valuation multiple could stay depressed for some time. Two near-term checks should help determine whether the group-wide selling has a fundamental basis. XPeng’s results, due before the U.S. market opens on Nov. 16, will be the first test. NIO’s November deliveries, due in early December, will be the next check on whether the company can get back on track toward its 40,000-per-month goal.