How Carney’s Shift Toward China Could Become Leverage in Stalled U.S. Trade Talks

Wait 5 sec.

Canada's Prime Minister Mark Carney shakes hands with China's President Xi Jinping at the APEC summit on Nov. 19, 2026. —China Pool––Getty ImagesCanadian Prime Minister Mark Carney is placing particular focus on renewing relations with China as he aims to deepen international trade ties and diversify from U.S. reliance amid a three-month-long trade war with the U.S.When asked what cards Canada holds in its ongoing talks with Washington, Carney, who recently announced a new partnership with the E.U., pointed to the country's budding relationships elsewhere.“Our cards are that everyone else in the world wants to deal with us,” he said Wednesday during a remote interview with the New York Times from Shenzhen, China, where he was among the world leaders attending the Asia-Pacific Economic Cooperation (APEC) summit. "If the U.S. doesn't want to do the deal, we're busy.” His remarks came in the wake of President Donald Trump's claim that the U.S. holds “all the cards” after trade talks collapsed in August, leading to both sides enforcing heavy retaliatory tariffs.Carney and Trump had a meeting on the sidelines of APEC, but aside from a commitment to “continue” negotiations and stay in close contact, no progress was made. However, Carney painted his meeting with Chinese President Xi Jinping in a much more positive light. Ahead of the summit, Carney and Xi announced a Canada-China trade pact, which provided additional tariff relief on Canadian food and agricultural exports into China, and in return saw Canada agree to extend tariff exemptions for certain Chinese steel and aluminum products by two years.Carney, who is promoting a “Canada Strong” platform as he aims to build economic resilience at home, touted the expansion of the trade arrangement with China as something that will deliver “greater certainty and prosperity for all Canadians.” He also praised the negotiation process with China, saying: “They’re very professional. They move forward in a very linear fashion.”In an eight-day tour that took him from a European summit in Ireland to the Philippines, Cambodia, and finally China for the APEC gathering, Carney forged ahead with his plan to diversify Canada's economy away from its dependence on the U.S., which by far remains the country's largest trading partner.Experts say Canada's progress in deepening its economic relationships with China could challenge Trump's insistence that Washington holds the upper hand in trade negotiations.“Part of the Trump Administration’s [belief] is that everybody needs the U.S. more than anything else, and therefore the U.S. has maximum leverage,” says Jennifer Hillman, co-director of the Institute of International Economic Law at Georgetown University. “What this is clearly saying is that Canada can afford to be less willing to give the U.S. whatever it asks for [in negotiations], because they have other options.”China has the world's second-largest economy, behind only the U.S., giving it the potential to become a much larger market for Canadian goods than some of the other countries Carney has sought to deepen relations with.“China represents a very big market and the potential of a really big trading partner,” says Lori Turnbull, a professor in the Faculty of Management at Dalhousie University, noting it could be a leverage point in U.S. negotiations. “Doing a deal with a country like China is something that [the U.S.] will care about because of the size of China's economy and its competitive relationship with the U.S.”Carney's latest push to strengthen trade ties with Beijing forms part of a months-long effort to renew Canada-China relations. In January, he met with Xi to forge what he called a “new strategic partnership,” agreeing to allow in up to 49,000 Chinese electric vehicles at a tariff of 6.1%, rather than the previous 100% levy. China agreed to lower tariffs on Canadian agricultural products, including canola seeds, a major Canadian export.The move drew criticism from Trump, who said that “China will eat Canada alive, completely devour it, including the destruction of their businesses, social fabric, and general way of life.”While Canada's closer relationship with China could strengthen its hand in negotiations, experts also warn that it could backfire.Turnbull points to the latest agreement to extend tariff exemptions on Chinese steel and aluminum as a potential source of tension with Washington. “Things like reducing tariffs on select steel and aluminum products coming from China is something that might make the U.S. and not just Donald Trump, but also [U.S. Trade Representative] Jamieson Greer angry,” she suggests.Steel, aluminum, and auto tariffs were among the major points of contention when U.S.-Canada trade negotiations broke down in August, with both sides accusing each other of walking back commitments.Carney, however, has played down concerns that Canada's growing trade relationship with China is a major issue for Trump.“In my conversation with the President, he’s tried to understand where we are with China, where we’re going with China,” said Carney during a news conference in Shenzhen. “I shouldn’t speak for him, but in his hierarchy of issues, it’s not the top issue at all.”Meanwhile, some Canadian officials have voiced concerns on expanding trade with China.Ontario Premier Doug Ford warned Carney on Monday against opening the door for more Chinese-made EV vehicles in Canada, arguing the “government’s focus needs to be on protecting Canadian auto workers, not undermining them by importing even more state-subsidized cheap Chinese cars.”Michael Chong, a lawmaker from Canada’s Conservative Party, during a press conference on Wednesday supported maintaining a dialogue with Beijing, but described Carney’s budding strategic partnership with China as a “risky gambit,” citing potential “national security” concerns. In 2025, Ottawa identified China as one of the main perpetrators of foreign interference and espionage against Canada alongside other countries such as Russia and Iran. The Canadian government’s own analysis of Canada-China relations also points out that there are "associated risks” in broader trade cooperation in key areas, such as “prevalent and persistent intellectual property theft, and the risk of diversion of sensitive goods and technologies intended for civilian use for military purposes and applications.”Carney said ahead of his Asia trip that he would raise concerns about foreign interference in his meeting with Xi. "The advantage of these meetings is you can raise issues directly and frankly,” he told reporters in Montreal on Nov. 10. Carney added that he would stress the importance Canada places on "the non-interference in our affairs by China and other countries.”In a press briefing during the APEC summit, Carney emphasized that Canada's trade with China is largely focused on commodities, rather than sensitive technologies such as advanced semiconductors.“We are exporting canola, we are exporting pork. We are exporting halibut,” Carney said, also citing liquefied natural gas and oil. “These are important industries. These are not cutting-edge semi-conductors.”Experts point out that Canada could pursue deeper cooperation with other international partners in sectors where a closer relationship with China would be more difficult, including defense and advanced technology.“[Canada] is not going to partner with China on defense, security, AI, and digital technology, things like that would be very difficult. [Carney] would have an impossible time trying to convince Canadians that's what we should be doing,” says Turnbull. “For those things, [Canada] would be putting [its] arms around the European Union.”In September, the European Union unveiled its vision for Canada to become an “associate member” of the bloc. During an E.U.-Canada summit in Montreal in October, the two sides underscored their commitment to this plan, paving the way for deeper cooperation in areas including AI, energy, critical minerals, quantum technology, and trade.Carney's efforts to expand Canada's trading relationships were on display throughout his trip to Asia. While attending the Association of Southeast Asian Nations (ASEAN) summit in Manila, the Philippines, Carney announced the conclusion of negotiations on two free trade agreements, one with the 11-country ASEAN bloc to expand Canada’s integration into Asian supply chains and another with the Philippines that once in force could increase exports up to three times by 2035, according to Prime Minister Carney's office.However, experts caution that while the new agreements could benefit Canada's economy and boost the country’s international standing, the scale of trade involved remains small compared to Canada's trade with the U.S., which accounted for 683.3 billion Canadian dollars in total exports in 2025.“Even though there's an effort to diversify, some of that has to include markets that would be large enough to absorb a significant amount of the Canadian supply,” Turnbull adds.Canadian Prime Minister Mark Carney speaks with U.S. President Donald Trump at the APEC summit in Shenzhen, China, on Nov. 19, 2026. —Qilai Shen––Bloomberg/Getty ImagesCarney considers Chinese automakers an option if U.S. talks failCarney has repeatedly emphasized that Canada will not accept a U.S. deal that undermines its auto industry in any way. In his interview with the New York Times, he indicated America First auto demands were holding up trade negotiations.He went on to say that China has a significant edge when it comes to electric vehicles, noting: “We are way behind in North America relative to China, as is Europe.”As the issue remains a core stumbling block in talks between Washington and Ottawa, Carney has suggested Canada could turn to Chinese automakers if U.S. trade negotiations fail.Speaking to reporters in Cambodia earlier this week, Carney said Canada could look to European and Asian carmakers, including Chinese manufacturers, to help sustain its auto manufacturing sector.“We have the best auto workers in the world, and we want them fully deployed, full opportunity, in an integrated North American market,” Carney said. “That market has become less integrated because of U.S. trade actions.”Asked whether the possibility of Chinese investment could serve as leverage in the negotiations with Washington, Carney replied that “it’s not leverage, but action, reaction.” He added that there are “great auto workers” and “real assets” in Canada, and if they’re “not fully utilized in a North America context,” then that “provides other opportunities." Canada will “move forward, either way,” he concluded.However, in addition to the concerns raised by some Canadian lawmakers, experts caution that turning to Chinese automakers would face significant practical and geographical challenges, given how closely integrated the North American automobile industry has become.“Geography is a huge limitation. It is much cheaper and more efficient for Canada to trade with the United States than it is with China,” says Hillman. “Secondly, you have to start with where we are today, which is a highly-integrated North American market. Trying to shift those supply chains, in and out of China, does present some commercial difficulties, and won't be done over a short period of time.”Carney himself pointed out last year that auto parts cross the U.S.-Canada border an average of six times before final assembly, underscoring how closely the two countries' manufacturing supply chains are connected.Carney's openness to turning to Chinese automakers has nevertheless drawn criticism from some in Washington, with White House trade adviser Peter Navarro taking to social media to voice his disapproval. “Are you really threatening to play China off the U.S.? This is offensive in the extreme. You should be far more worried [that] China is going to eat Canada alive,” Navarro said, echoing comments previously made by Trump. Navarro’s warning was reposted by Pete Hoekstra, the U.S. ambassador to Canada.Despite the challenges and backlash, experts tell TIME that the mere prospect of Canada turning to Chinese manufacturers could itself provide leverage in negotiations with Washington, particularly given U.S. concerns about Chinese competition in the North American auto market.“If the U.S. wants to keep China out, partnering with Canada is a way to do that,” says Turnbull. “If they don't do that, and [Canada wants to] partner with China, then the U.S. potentially loses the control it has over the North American auto market.”