Why the Supreme Court’s environmental watchdog wants to curb riverbed sand mining, and what it proposes instead

Wait 5 sec.

Earlier this month, the Supreme Court’s Central Empowered Committee (CEC) proposed a three-year roadmap to phase out unsustainable sand mining and a plan to desilt and dredge dam reservoirs to recover sediment for use as construction material.The recommendations, which the court is yet to examine in detail, came in a suo motu case concerning illegal sand mining in the National Chambal Sanctuary. In October, the court expanded the scope of the case and asked the CEC to submit a report on riverbed sand mining.The CEC said that while excessive and unsustainable sand mining is damaging river ecosystems, reservoirs are losing storage capacity because of accumulated sediment. It suggested framing a national policy to recover and use suitable sediment as an alternative source of construction material.Demand for sand continues to grow amid a spate of infrastructure and construction projects in the country, driving up extraction. But the growing ecological costs have made it necessary to curb unsustainable mining.Why does the CEC want unsustainable riverbed sand extraction phased out?The CEC’s central argument is that rivers are not merely channels carrying water but dynamic systems that depend on a natural balance between water flow and sediment movement. Sand, gravel and silt are integral to maintaining riverbed elevation, channel stability, groundwater recharge and aquatic habitats.Excessive removal of sand, especially from deep within the riverbed, can disrupt the natural subterranean barrier, allowing surrounding groundwater to drain into the river channel. This can dry up wells and deplete aquifers. To compensate for the excess extraction, a river erodes its own banks and bed.Also in Explained | Why counting farm fires is not enough to measure the scale of stubble burningThe committee distinguishes between scientific extraction and indiscriminate mining. Scientific mining involves limited removal, such as skimming the upper layer of sandbars deposited after the monsoon, rather than excavating deep pits. However, given the environmental consequences and persistent enforcement failures, it wants a progressive transition away from unsustainable extraction from active river channels.Story continues below this adExcessive sand extraction also damages aquatic and riparian habitats, along with the plants and wildlife that depend on them. The CEC has also noted changes in water flow, velocity and discharge capacity, which can, in turn, make infrastructure vulnerable.There have been instances of such damage and risks to infrastructure. In 2010, the Bombay High Court banned sand mining using suction pumps from the bed of the Vaitarna River in Palghar district (then part of Thane district), citing the threat to an important railway bridge. Similarly, in 2024, the Kalwa-Nangal bridge over the Swan River in Punjab, connecting Ropar to Garhshankar, was damaged due to excessive sand extraction from the riverbed.Why has desiltation of dams and reservoirs been proposed as an alternative?The Supreme Court’s environmental watchdog feels that scientific desiltation of dams and reservoirs could provide a substantial alternative source of sand and aggregates. Desiltation involves removing accumulated silt, sand, clay and other sediment and debris from a reservoir.Story continues below this adReservoirs, it noted, intercept and retain substantial quantities of sediment transported by rivers, gradually reducing their storage capacity. This affects their core functions, such as irrigation, hydropower generation, and drinking water supply.The CEC sees an opportunity in the sediment accumulating behind dams. It has argued that recovering suitable sand and gravel from these deposits could serve two purposes: restoring reservoir capacity and supplying construction material without placing additional pressure on active river channels.The CEC cited government data presented in Parliament to illustrate the loss of reservoir storage capacity due to sedimentation. According to Central Water Commission assessments, 439 reservoirs had lost an average of 19.24% of their original gross storage capacity because of sedimentation.Their average annual capacity loss was approximately 0.74%. Of these, 23 reservoirs had lost more than 50% of their original storage capacity, another 23 had lost between 40% and 50%, and 49 had lost between 30% and 40%. These figures reflect the extent of sediment accumulation.Story continues below this adAlso Read | Mekedatu project: Why Karnataka’s proposed Cauvery dam has reignited water-sharing row with TNThe CEC also cited the example of Gobind Sagar reservoir behind the Bhakra Dam. Its original gross storage capacity of 9,868 million cubic metres has declined to approximately 7,300 million cubic metres, a loss of 2,568 million cubic metres, or around 26%, due to sedimentation.The Bhakra Beas Management Board has explored desiltation and dredging proposals for the Bhakra and Pong reservoirs. Its April 2026 expression of interest estimated annual sediment inflows of 35–40 million cubic metres into Bhakra and 25 million cubic metres into Pong.However, the CEC cautions that not all accumulated sediment can be used as construction-grade sand. Material must undergo grain-size, mineralogical and quality testing. Fine silt and clay may be unsuitable for conventional construction, while sand and gravel could have commercial value. Desiltation must also account for downstream turbidity, aquatic habitats, dam safety and the ecological consequences of sediment removal, the CEC said.It has thus recommended that central authorities develop a national reservoir sediment management policy or programme. This, it said, should include a ten-year desiltation cycle, reservoir-wise sediment assessments, quality testing, environmental safeguards, dam safety requirements and provisions for the beneficial use of recovered material.Story continues below this adIt has also recommended assessing storage dams more than 15 years old that have yet to undergo systematic desiltation, and prioritising them for the exercise.How extensive is illegal sand mining, and what do government figures tell us?The CEC also highlighted the problem of illegal mining. It identified outdated District Survey Reports, poorly demarcated mining boundaries, outdated replenishment studies, extraction beyond permitted depths and quantities, night-time operations and forged transit permits as major enforcement failures.Importantly, even holding a mining lease or environmental clearance does not establish that actual extraction is taking place within approved boundaries and limits, it noted. The scale of the problem is difficult to establish because India does not maintain a consolidated national database of sand extraction, consumption or illegal sand mining volumes.NewsletterFollow our daily newsletter so you never miss anything important. On Wednesday, we answer readers' questions.SubscribeThe CEC cited Ministry of Mines data showing 95,306 illegal mining cases involving major and minor minerals in 2021-22 across reporting states. However, these figures are not specific to sand mining, and the quantity extracted remains unknown.Story continues below this adAs for legal extraction, there is no reliable consolidated national figure for the quantity of sand legally mined from rivers. Sand is classified as a minor mineral under the Mines and Minerals (Development and Regulation) Act, 1957, and its regulation rests primarily with state governments. A 2019 Lok Sabha reply explicitly stated that data on sand-mining activity was not maintained centrally. The absence of reliable data on legal production and illegal extraction is itself a significant governance problem.