SUPPORT ETHIOPIA INSIGHT .wpedon-container .wpedon-select, .wpedon-container .wpedon-input { width: 200px; min-width: 200px; max-width: 200px; } Both the party and the federal government must earn public trust through reform and deliveryWhat lies ahead for Tigray? Some, particularly officials of the federal government and Tigray Peace Force (TPF), believe the TPLF is finished. TPLF and TDF leaders, however, present a different narrative. While both emphasize the possibility of a comeback, some acknowledge temporary territorial losses, while others characterize the withdrawal as a strategic retreat.These competing narratives overlook two more important questions: What explains the TPLF’s recent setbacks, and what will determine Tigray’s political future?I argue that the TPLF’s defeat is primarily a political leadership failure, reflected in at least five major miscalculations. Its future, however, is not settled. Much will depend on what the federal government and the TPLF do next.Political MiscalculationsAfter years of devastating conflict, the people of Tigray are exhausted by war. This reality is evident even to an ordinary observer, yet it appears not to have been adequately reflected in the TPLF leadership’s calculations. The leadership seems to have underestimated the people’s desire for peace, recovery, and normal life.Unlike the 2020–2022 war, which was largely understood as a war on Tigray by external forces, the recent conflict has a strong internal dimension. It reflects divisions between those in power and Tigrayans who feel excluded, marginalized, or unheard.In my assessment, internal dissatisfaction and its mishandling contributed more to the TPLF’s defeat than the federal government’s military strength. Federal involvement mattered, but internal divisions and declining political support were more decisive. Presenting this conflict as just another war for Tigray’s survival therefore risks misreading its nature. Internal grievances cannot be overcome simply by invoking an external threat.Historically, the TPLF relied heavily on persuasion to recruit fighters, while generally leaving the final decision to the individual. During the recent conflict, reported forced conscription, backed by harsh laws, marked a significant departure from that tradition. Reports of mothers being detained and pressured to produce their children for recruitment disappointed many. Pointing to compulsory national service elsewhere does not resolve questions of individual rights, public consent, and political legitimacy.The TPLF also appears to have underestimated the international support Abiy Ahmed’s government could mobilize. Ethiopia’s strategic location, regional importance, and position on the Nile give it considerable geopolitical influence.Publicly declaring an intention to remove Abiy from power, whether as a genuine objective, domestic rhetoric, or an attempt to pressure him, also raises questions about whether the diplomatic consequences were carefully considered.The leadership appears to have underestimated the adversary’s technology, financial resources, manpower, and ability to sustain conflict. Despite receiving cautionary advice, it also seems to have overestimated the support available from the “Alliance for Survival.”Misjudging an opponent’s strength while placing excessive confidence in allies can lead to unrealistic strategies and costly setbacks.Taken together, these failures suggest that the TPLF’s defeat was not simply the result of superior military force. It was fundamentally a political leadership failure, manifested in poor judgment and a growing disconnect from the people.Federal ResponsibilitiesThe TPLF’s setbacks do not necessarily settle Tigray’s political future. Neither its complete disappearance nor a comeback can be ruled out entirely.I argue that the outcome will depend mainly on how the federal government and the TPLF respond to the people’s needs and aspirations.If the federal government delivers peace, humanitarian relief, resettlement, development, and democratic self-government while the TPLF continues to repeat its mistakes, the party’s decline could deepen. Conversely, if the government fails to deliver while the TPLF reforms, conditions for renewed support could emerge. The main tests facing the federal government are clear.Peace must come first. Military gains should not be mistaken for the end of the war. Reports of senior TPLF politicians and commanders surrendering suggest that the organization is weakening, but the risk of continued instability remains. Declaring the war over does not make it so.The federal government should therefore seek a negotiated settlement with the leadership, creating a path from armed struggle to peaceful political participation. Success means ending the cycle of war, not merely defeating an armed opponent.The federal government should distinguish between criticism of the TPLF’s political leadership and attacks on Tigray’s history and collective legacy. Tigrayans’ historical experiences, including the struggle in which the TPLF played a central role, remain important to many people, even among those who disagree with the party’s current leadership. Political messaging that targets Tigrayan history and identity could turn dissatisfaction with the party into solidarity with it.People urgently need food, medicine, and essential services. Humanitarian assistance should receive the same urgency as security operations and should not wait for the completion of disarmament, demobilization, and reintegration (DDR). Success should be measured by assistance actually reaching hungry families, patients, and displaced communities, not by announcements.The return of displaced people, particularly those from Western Tigray, is essential to lasting peace. The federal government should address territorial disputes through peaceful and constitutional means while taking immediate steps to ensure security, disarm armed elements threatening returnees, and address the occupation of displaced families’ homes and farmland.Peace must bring visible economic improvement, particularly for young people. The federal government should restart major projects suspended during the war and launch new investments, including infrastructure rehabilitation and job-creating initiatives. Restored services, functioning infrastructure, and employment opportunities would give people tangible reasons to believe in peace.The federal government must understand that Tigrayans seek political agency, the right to shape their own future, administer their affairs, and freely choose their leaders. Respecting Tigray’s constitutional right to self-government is therefore essential. Imposing political leadership from outside risks reviving grievances.But self-government should not mean returning power to one party. Tigray needs a broad political framework, a big tent, where all parties participate and compete under equal rules, without special privileges. The federal government’s role should be to enable this process, not determine its outcome.TPLF’s ChoicesThe TPLF must reconsider whether its current leadership can respond to the new political reality. In my assessment, a meaningful recovery under the current leadership would be difficult. New leadership must bring better judgment, public acknowledgment of past mistakes and a better vision for Tigray’s future. Replacing individuals without political reform would achieve little.The TPLF must also recognize that the people do not want another war. Continued fighting would exacerbate suffering and could further weaken its political standing. It should pursue every credible opportunity for a negotiated settlement rather than assume that renewed confrontation will restore its former position.The party should recognize that its former near-exclusive control over Tigray’s political, military, and administrative institutions cannot simply be assumed to return. Its future should be as a civilian political party competing peacefully with others. Its strength must come from its political program and ability to win votes, not military power, media control, or privileged access to government resources. Political authority must be earned through elections, not inherited from past struggles.The TPLF must distinguish between the interests of its leaders, the party, and the people of Tigray. If it claims to represent the people, it must recognize that endless war cannot serve their interests. It should address internal grievances, accept necessary compromises, and seize credible opportunities for peace, even at the cost of reduced political power. The question is not how the TPLF can restore its former dominance, but how it can contribute to Tigray’s peace and recovery.The party must also better understand the strategic interests and priorities of the international community. Diplomacy requires realistic judgment, not wishful thinking.It must reassess its relationships with external forces whose interests may not align with those of Tigray. Depending on such alliances could undermine its credibility, limit diplomatic opportunities, and complicate prospects for peace. The TPLF’s diplomatic strategy should be guided by Tigray’s long-term interests, not by the agendas of external powers.The TPLF’s recent setbacks raise serious questions about its leadership and strategic judgment. But military defeat alone will not determine its political future, just as military victory will not guarantee the federal government’s success.The federal government’s challenge is to turn military gains into peace, humanitarian relief, reconstruction, and democratic self-government. The TPLF’s challenge is to learn from its mistakes, renew itself, reassess its external alliances, and accept a role based on public consent rather than military or institutional power.Ultimately, Tigray’s future will depend less on who claims victory today than on who earns the people’s trust through concrete actions. Military power may determine who controls territory, but only political legitimacy and public confidence can sustain peace. .wpedon-container .wpedon-select, .wpedon-container .wpedon-input { width: 200px; min-width: 200px; max-width: 200px; } Query or correction? Email us window.addEventListener("sfsi_functions_loaded", function(){if (typeof sfsi_widget_set == "function") {sfsi_widget_set();}}); While this commentary contains the author’s opinions, Ethiopia Insight will correct factual errors.Main photo: Prime Minister Abiy Ahmed with federal government representatives and members of the newly established Tigray Interim Administration at its inauguration ceremony. Addis Ababa, October 2026. Source: Office of the Prime Minister, X.Published under Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial 4.0 International licence. You may not use the material for commercial purposes.The post The TPLF’s Setbacks Do Not Determine Tigray’s Political Future appeared first on Ethiopia Insight.