Fudd Friday: The Bullard Could Have Been Our Lever-Action Of Choice

Wait 5 sec.

You have to admire the geniuses in Winchester Repeating Arms' history. Despite the very real limitations of their Model 94, it became the best-selling sporting rifle in history, and that by a wide margin. And that wasn’t their only successful lever-action; for decades, they dominated this market with rifles like the Model 92, the Model 71, the Model 1873, the Model 88 and others. Marlin and Savage did have their popular alternatives, but they were very much second to Winchester’s dominance. It didn’t have to be this way, because if you look at the rise of Winchester over the late 1800s, there were other companies that could have seriously challenged their sales, with rifles like the Bullard Large Frame lever-action seen here.Non-Winchester Lever-Actions @ TFB:Smith & Wesson X Vortex: Ready-to-Hunt Model 1854 Packages Fudd Friday: The State Of The Lever-Action Union The Rimfire Report: Do You Have The Green For This Historic Henry? Fudd Friday: Escape From SHOT - Las Vegas Antique Arms Show 2026 What’s a Bullard Rifle?After the Civil War, there was a boom in repeating rifle development. Everyone remembers Benjamin Tyler Henry’s 1860 rifle, which became the Winchester 1866 rifle, influencing firearms progress to this day. Most gun geeks remember the Spencer too, which was considerably different from the Henry design. The Spencer faded away after the Civil War; it was produced until the mid-1870s, but more conventional lever-action designs prevailed.Winchester dominated sales in that Wild West era, but there were other manufacturers who saw the potential in firearms sales and tried their own lever-action designs—including the Whitney-Kennedy and Whitney-Burgess designs and the Bullard design seen here, along with the already-mentioned Marlin and Savage (who survive to this day, unlike Bullard and Whitney’s collaborative work). The Bullards might be the most desirable American sporting rifles of that generation. The company was founded by James Herbert Bullard, a prolific inventor (he had 100 patents filed in his lifetime) as well as an industrial leader. Bullard was a friend of Daniel B. Wesson, and was involved with Wesson’s firearms manufacturing (both as an inventor and as a mechanic for the Smith & Wesson factory). To show you what kind of a guy he was, take this story from the American Society of Arms Collectors. In their write-up on Bullard, they say he invented a machine for checkering handgun grips in 1878, and it was still in use at the Smith & Wesson plant in 1971.Clearly, Bullard was a very sharp cookie. By the early 1880s, the titans of the gunmaking industry had moved on from building pistol-caliber rifles to much heavier-caliber repeaters that could take down big game. Around that time, Bullard dropped his other gigs and set up a company to build firearms of his own design, both single-shot rifles and repeaters.The single-shots are worthy of their own write-up, but the gun seen here is one of Bullard’s lever-actions. He had two main patterns for his repeaters. There was a smaller-framed rifle that fired lower-powered cartridges like the pistol-caliber rounds that other companies used. There was also a large-framed rifle that came in cartridges such as .45-70, aimed at big game. Why buy a Bullard? His rifles were known for their smooth operation, thanks to a rack-and-pinion actuation setup, not the more awkward-handling designs of his competitors. And there were some other differences, such as the bottom ejection and loading, which could have appealed to left-handed shooters. And, if you’re making a product that appears to be the finest-made in its corner of the industry, someone will always want it—and that’s what Bullard offered. Not only were his rifles mechanically complex and enjoyable to shoot, but Bullard’s factory also offered customized jobs like the rifle seen here. Winchester also did these special-order rifles, and did them very well, but Bullard could give you a very beautiful gun for your money.But Bullard couldn’t compete with Winchester on affordability; Bullard’s designs were complicated to build, with hand-fitted parts that are often compared to an old mechanical watch. This means more man-hours in production, which in turn means a higher price. People bought Marlins or Winchesters instead, for that reason. Bullard stopped building rifles in 1891.Perhaps, given Bullard’s mechanical genius, he could have devised a rifle that was more easily mass-produced and saved the company, but he was distracted by other inventions and projects through the 1880s and was not as hands-on an owner/operator as he could have been. He did not own a majority share in the company, either. It is interesting to conjecture where he could have taken the firearms industry, but it doesn’t really matter—the company is never coming back, and no outfit like Chiappa is likely to resurrect the designs, either, considering how complex they are. Depending on who you ask, Bullard’s production ranges from a low estimate of 2,800 rifles to a high estimate of 12,000 rifles, but whichever number is correct, they’re not making any more. The rifle seen in these photos is for sale at the December 4 Rock Island auction in Bedford, Texas. They list it as a “Scarce and Desirable Semi-Deluxe Bullard Large Frame Lever Action Rifle,” and say the special options on the rifle make it a rare find, with the following details in the description:“Finding Bullard's in this high of condition is also very difficult. It has a Winchester style German silver blade front sight and notch and folding latter rear sight on the part octagon barrel, "Cal/45" on top of the receiver ring, "BULLARD REPEATING ARMS COMPANY/SPRINGFIELD MASS U.S.A. PAT. AUG. 16. 1881." on the left side of the receiver, "EA110" on the bottom, and a smooth semi-pistol grip buttstock with nice flame figure and the checkered Bullard buttplate.” They describe the condition as “Very fine with 85% plus original blue finish on the receiver, 50% of the fading original blue finish on the barrel which is turning to a smooth brown, the vast majority of the bright original case colors on the hammer and lever, and rich niter blue on the rolling block.” Of course, there are some nicks and imperfections on the rifle, but it’s mechanically excellent and “a very fine Bullard in a rare configuration.” They estimate the winning bid will be in the $5,500 to $8,500 range. See more here.All photos: Rock Island AuctionsIf this post has you ready to hit the range, head over to gunranges.com - a free directory to help you find shooting ranges near you, wherever you are in the United States.