Seismometers pick up 3,000-square-mile sonic boom carpet, a microphone alternative

Wait 5 sec.

Seismometers that normally track earthquakes may help set noise standards for a new generation of supersonic aircraft. Penn State researchers used existing seismic networks to detect and map sonic booms from supersonic test flights, offering a possible alternative to costly microphone arrays.The study is part of Project 57, Penn State’s arm of the FAA’s ASCENT Center of Excellence.Why booms need measuringSonic booms occur when shock waves from an aircraft flying faster than sound compress into a loud roar on the ground. Noise complaints and damage led the FAA to ban commercial supersonic flight over land in the United States in 1973.In July, the FAA announced it is moving from a blanket speed-based ban to a noise-based certification standard, since designs like NASA’s Quesst X-59 may lessen boom impacts.Microphones are the traditional tool, but the equipment is expensive and must be deployed in large numbers.Mapping the primary boomThe researchers matched the dates and times of supersonic flights at Edwards Air Force Base in Southern California against seismic recordings. The flights included 2005 tests flown by the FAA for a study led by Vic Sparrow and a 2022 flight for a commemorative air show.Led by geosciences professor Andy Nyblade, the team compared flight details with ground-shaking data from archives including NSF’s SAGE facility and two California earthquake data centers.Several seismometers recorded a boom signal, revealing a “carpet” of primary boom covering about 3,000 square miles (7,800 square kilometers) just west of the base. That fit expectations, since primary booms travel directly from the aircraft to the ground.Secondary booms varySecondary booms, quieter rumbles that stretch diagonally ahead of the flight path, were harder to find. Whether they can be detected depends on local weather, upper-atmosphere winds and turbulence.In one type, a boom ascends from the top of the aircraft, bounces off the atmospheric boundary and bends back to the ground. In another, the primary boom reflects off the ground, bounces off the atmosphere and is refracted back down.Former postdoctoral scholar Sampath Rathnayaka searched seismic data from about 37 to 186 miles (96 to 482 kilometers) from the base. He used ray tracing, a method that roughly estimates where secondary signals would land, along with aircraft trajectories and online weather profiles for each flight.Signal arrival timing, visual comparison among nearby seismometers and signal-to-noise ratios then showed which instruments recorded secondary booms, said Rathnayaka, the study’s corresponding author. Up to 26 seismometers recorded them for the 2005 flights, implying a secondary carpet of about 11,600 square miles (30,000 square kilometers). The 2022 flights produced no secondary booms because of atmospheric conditions.From shaking to noiseGround shaking from shock waves can be recorded much like earthquakes, even from aircraft flying just a bit faster than sound, Nyblade said. The next step is comparing shaking amplitudes with microphone recordings to see whether seismic data can stand in for what people would hear.The team calls the work a case study limited to Southern California seismic networks. If it scales to larger networks across the U.S., the data could help establish a noise-based standard for future supersonic flights.Sparrow, who co-leads Project 57, said the work so far shows seismometers could serve “as a surrogate for microphones,” so the team now turns to scaling up.The study was published in the Journal of the Acoustical Society of America.