Reels, robes and Rule 36: Where Bar Council draws the line for lawyer-influencers

Wait 5 sec.

The growing presence of lawyers on social media has brought into focus a restriction that has regulated the legal profession in India for a long time – advocates cannot advertise their services or solicit work, directly or indirectly. The issue has become relevant particularly because a number of lawyers use platforms such as Instagram, YouTube and LinkedIn to build a public profile, explain legal developments, and engage with audiences.Rule 36 of the Bar Council of India (BCI) Rules bars advocates from soliciting work or advertising, directly or indirectly. It says an advocate “shall not solicit work or advertise, either directly or indirectly, whether by circulars, advertisements, touts, personal communications, interviews not warranted by personal relations, furnishing or inspiring newspaper comments or producing his photographs to be published in connection with cases in which he has been engaged or concerned.”The rule allows only limited information on a lawyer’s website, as set out in its Schedule – name, address, telephone number, email ID, enrolment particulars, Bar association membership, professional and academic qualifications, and broad areas of practice.What counts as indirect advertising?With lawyers increasingly using social media to share videos and commentary on legal developments, the question is how the prohibition on indirect advertising applies to such content.In a circular issued in July 2026, the BCI said that social media content such as reels, short videos, thumbnails, dramatic posts, chamber-display clips, court-corridor videos, promotional internship posts, “lawyer life” content and edited hearing clips could, depending on their content and purpose, amount to indirect advertising.According to BCI, the test was not merely whether a post expressly asked viewers to “hire me” or “contact me”. Instead, it said, the content had to be assessed as a whole to determine whether it used court premises, judicial proceedings, professional work, a lawyer’s robe or chamber, client matters, litigation experience or internships to promote the advocate, build a personal brand, gain followers or commercially exploit access to the legal profession.The circular also warned against packaging legal content as clickbait to attract potential clients through claims such as “guaranteed bail”, “divorce in a few days”, “sure acquittal”, “assured stay”, “instant relief” or “special court connection”. Such claims, it said, could suggest certainty of outcome, special influence or shortcuts to justice, and mislead people seeking legal assistance.Story continues below this adSpeaking to The Indian Express, BCI member Ashish Panjabrao Deshmukh says an advocate cannot publish paid advertisements claiming to be the best criminal lawyer, matrimonial lawyer or constitutional lawyer. Nor can an advocate guarantee success in litigation, publicise exaggerated success rates, pay intermediaries for referrals or use sponsored campaigns intended to procure briefs.Also Read | Madhya Pradesh viral video: Can cops quiz unmarried couples in hotels? What law saysHowever, he clarifies that every public communication by an advocate does not constitute prohibited advertising. Explaining judgments, legislative developments and legal principles, participating in academic seminars and conducting legal awareness programmes would not automatically amount to advertising, Deshmukh says.For instance, explaining the statutory requirements for obtaining bail would ordinarily be considered legal education. However, using such content to guarantee a bail order, publicise one’s professional achievements or invite prospective litigants to engage one’s services could amount to indirect advertising. “The decisive distinction is whether the communication genuinely informs or educates the public or whether it is being used, directly or indirectly, to advertise the advocate, secure clients or commercially promote professional services,” he says.Similarly, explaining the constitutional principles arising from a Supreme Court judgment is different from repeatedly publicising the advocate’s own appearances and favourable orders for attracting professional engagements. The BCI, Deshmukh states, has made it clear that even where information is publicly available, its presentation may become objectionable if it is selectively distorted, sensationalised or used to attract professional engagements.Story continues below this adOn the question of whether the BCI considers monetisation of legal content to be a violation of professional conduct rules, he says receiving payment for writing a legal textbook or delivering an academic lecture would be different from operating a paid promotional platform to attract clients. Monetisation, Deshmukh adds, was not automatically professional misconduct, but the nature of the content, purpose of monetisation and financial arrangements would have to be examined.Why are lawyers prohibited from advertising?The prohibition is rooted in the BCI’s view that the legal profession is different from a commercial business. Unlike businesses that compete for customers through promotional campaigns, the practice of law is considered a profession centred on public service, justice and professional integrity. The BCI stresses that lawyers should not commercialise their services or seek clients through advertisements and promotional activities. Advocate Prasannakumar Manohar Joshi, who has over 200,000 Instagram followers, says he makes videos in Marathi to simplify legal concepts. (Image source: Screengrab from Instagram)In a press release issued on March 17, 2025, the BCI said commercialisation of legal services through advertising and solicitation could erode public trust in the profession and undermine its dignity.Another concern highlighted by BCI is the spread of misleading legal information by self-styled legal influencers, including individuals who may not possess the requisite qualifications or credentials. It said inaccurate interpretations of laws and landmark judgments concerning matrimonial disputes, taxation, intellectual property rights, citizenship and privacy could cause confusion, lead people to make misguided legal decisions and add to the burden on courts.Story continues below this adThe Supreme Court has previously underscored the distinction between a profession and a commercial enterprise. In Bar Council of Maharashtra v M V Dabholkar (1975), Justice V R Krishna Iyer observed: “Law is no trade, briefs no merchandise, and so the leaven of commercial competition or procurement should not vulgarise the legal profession.”Similarly, in P N Vignesh v Chairman and Members of the Bar Council and Others, the Madras High Court observed that the legal profession is not, and can never be, treated as a business. It said that while a business is driven primarily by profit, a substantial part of the legal profession involves service to society. The fee paid to a lawyer, the court observed, is in recognition of the lawyer’s time and knowledge.In that case, the court directed state Bar Councils to initiate disciplinary proceedings against advocates advertising and soliciting work through online service providers. It emphasised that the delivery of justice is founded on constitutional principles and that lawyers, as upholders of the law, cannot treat their profession as a business. It also warned that unregulated advertisements by lawyers could mislead the public.Former BCI member Jitendra Sharma says the ban on advertising rests on two ideas. Once a lawyer joins the profession, he says, the focus should stay on the legal practice alone and if advertising were permitted, it would lead to “a blind race” that would harm the noble profession.Story continues below this adOn how the BCI decides what counts as advertising, Sharma points to the process rather than a checklist: “The council has a disciplinary committee that investigates allegations of misconduct against advocates. A complaint goes before the committee, which hears the parties and then decides whether the act amounts to misconduct.”He says an advocate who explains a judgment on YouTube or Instagram would prima facie be seen as making an awareness video, since the lawyer is not promoting himself. However, he draws a limit. Explaining a judgment is fine, he says, while openly giving an opinion on it is not allowed.Deshmukh says the prohibition on advertising stems from the legal profession’s distinct position in the justice system. “Unlike an ordinary trade or business, the legal profession is closely linked to the administration of justice and must not be driven by commercial competition,” he says.Citing the Supreme Court’s observation that “law is no trade, briefs no merchandise”, he says advocates cannot treat professional briefs as merchandise or acquire clients through commercial publicity inconsistent with professional dignity.Story continues below this adWhat has BCI said about legal influencers?The BCI has repeatedly cautioned advocates against using digital platforms to promote their services. In its March 17, 2025 press release, the council expressed concern over what it described as the increasingly prevalent practice of advocates advertising their legal services through social media, promotional videos and influencer endorsements.It also objected to the involvement of celebrities and digital platforms in promoting legal practices. The council said the rise of self-styled legal influencers had compounded these concerns, particularly where individuals without appropriate credentials were disseminating misleading information on important legal issues.In July 2026, the BCI issued a more detailed circular addressing lawyers’ conduct on social media. Among other things, it addressed misleading legal influencer content, clickbait guarantees, undisclosed AI-generated legal content, improper digital self-promotion, and the misuse of professional identity on social media and other digital platforms.Also Read | Meet Zoya, Zara: Thrown out as kids, these trans women now help others access legal aidThe BCI, however, clarified that it did not intend to discourage responsible legal awareness, academic discussion of judgments, accurate legal reporting, public legal education, constitutional literacy, neutral case-law updates, academic lectures, articles or seminars. It also permitted the responsible use of official court information and respectful discussion of legal principles emerging from judgments and orders.Story continues below this adThe distinction, according to the council, is between legitimate legal education and content that becomes promotional, sensational, misleading, mocking, defamatory, scandalising, contemptuous or commercially exploitative.What legal influencers sayAdvocate Sharad Bansal, a Delhi-based litigation lawyer with 21 years of experience and around 1.22 lakh Instagram followers, says he began creating legal content to help law students and young lawyers understand the practical aspects of litigation, which he felt were inadequately covered in law schools. Coming from a family of lawyers,  he had himself struggled to understand court procedures when he began practising in 2005. He says his content was therefore primarily intended to explain procedural aspects of law to junior lawyers and fresh graduates.Addressing concerns on indirect advertising, Bansal says he makes it clear on his social media channels that his videos are meant mainly for law students and freshers. He does not invite viewers to approach him for cases or offer to take up their matters. “In fact, I have got so good followership on Instagram. I never got any case from it,” he states, adding that his objective was to share honest and authentic legal knowledge and make people more aware of the law. If the content also helps the general public, he is “more than happy” about it, since ignorance of the law is no excuse and people need some way to become aware of it, he emphasises. Advocate Sharad Bansal, who has around 1.22 lakh Instagram followers, said he began creating legal content to help law students and young lawyers understand the practical aspects of litigation. (Image source: Screengrab from Instagram)Responding to whether the current rules in place are sufficiently clear for lawyers who create online content, Bansal says the existing rules are not sufficiently clear for lawyers creating content online. There is no clear demarcation on what subjects lawyers could discuss on social media.Story continues below this adAdvocate Prasannakumar Manohar Joshi, who has been practising for over 25 years and has over 200,000 followers on Instagram, says he started creating legal content on social media to make the law more accessible to ordinary citizens and counter the spread of misleading legal information online.Joshi says he deliberately makes videos in Marathi to explain legal provisions and complicated concepts in simple language, particularly for people who may find statutes and court judgments in English difficult to understand. “My objective is not to create clients through social media. It is to create legally informed citizens,” he shares.While supporting the Bar Council of India’s efforts to prevent commercial advertising and misleading promotions, Joshi says the rules should distinguish between genuine legal education and solicitation. “I believe the existing professional framework should be accompanied by practical and clear guidance on responsible digital communication.”Also Read | ‘How many times will she be dehumanised?’: Bilkis Bano’s lawyer on fresh relief to convictsJoshi believes that social media has become one of the most effective ways of reaching ordinary citizens. According to him, responsible legal awareness should be encouraged, while misleading information, commercial solicitation, sensationalism and misuse of professional identity should be discouraged. “My position is simple: we should regulate the misuse of social media without discouraging responsible legal education,” he explains.Joshi also cautions against equating a lawyer’s social media following with professional competence. A large audience, he says, gives an advocate greater reach but does not necessarily make them a better lawyer. “I consider a large audience more of a responsibility than a professional advantage,” he adds.Do the rules need more clarity?Sharma says specific guidelines for lawyers who work as legal influencers are in progress, and he considers them necessary. The existing rules, he says, date from a time when technology was far less advanced, and in the era of Artificial Intelligence or AI, detailed regulation is needed.The BCI has already taken substantial steps to regulate the misuse of social media and digital platforms by advocates and that the existing professional conduct rules provide the fundamental legal framework, Deshmukh says, adding that the BCI does not oppose technological advancement, academic collaboration, legal education or responsible dissemination of legal knowledge.“What must be prevented is the conversion of professional legal practice into an ordinary commercial enterprise in which legal briefs are treated as merchandise, professional standing is marketed through paid publicity and independent legal judgment becomes subordinate to commercial interests,” he clarifies.