The state has challenged the Uttarakhand Public Services Tribunal’s order. (AI-generated Image)The Uttarakhand government has withheld the retirement benefits of a constable who had worked with the state police and retired in 2022, claiming that he was paid Rs 23.08 lakh in excess salary during his service period.Now, the Uttarakhand High Court has upheld an order that denied the state government to recover this amount and held that the constable has not committed “fraud” by receiving an excess amount.A bench of Chief Justice Manoj Kumar Tiwari and Justice Subhash Upadhyay was acting on a plea filed by the state challenging the Uttarakhand Public Services Tribunal’s order.“It is not the case of the petitioners that the respondent committed fraud by receiving an excess amount, or that he was instrumental in any manner in getting such excess amount released in his favour, nor is it the case of the petitioners that the respondent ever submitted an undertaking before the Tribunal that he will refund the excess amount if it is found that he is not entitled to such payment,” the court said on November 17.Also Read | ‘State counsel missing in important matter’: Jharkhand High Court in JPSC exam caseThe bench noted that the Uttarakhand Public Service Tribunal had considered the matter in detail and relied on the Supreme Court’s judgment in State of Punjab v Rafiq Masih.In the absence of any such pleading, the ruling held that it did not find any reason to interfere with the view taken by the tribunal.The state has challenged the Uttarakhand Public Services Tribunal’s order, which allowed the recovery of Rs 23.08 lakh from the gratuity payable to a constable in the Uttarakhand Police who retired on December 31, 2022. Following his retirement, the state authorities withheld his pension and other retirement benefits. The state was seeking the amount on the ground that he had received excess salary payments during his service.Story continues below this adThe authorities, through an order dated June 1, 2023, directed him to deposit the excess amount or furnish an undertaking allowing its recovery from his gratuity. The constable challenged the recovery order before the State Public Services Tribunal, arguing that he had neither misrepresented facts nor played any role in securing the excess payment.Representing the State, Additional Advocate General Ganesh Datt Kandpal argued that as many as 19 punishments were imposed upon the constable between 1997 and 2003 and that he was well aware that he was not entitled to the amount which he received as salary.He further alleged that he was well aware that he was not entitled to the amount which he received as salary, yet he never apprised the departmental authorities about the excess amount which he received as salary.The tribunal, in its December 20, 2024 order, allowed his plea, set aside the recovery order, and directed the authorities to release his pension and other retirement benefits within 60 days. The state government then challenged the tribunal’s order before high court.Jagriti Rai works with The Indian Express (Digital), where she writes from the vital intersection of... Read More Tags:constableUttarakhand High Court