Why Shiv Sena has seized on Savarkar references in Sonia Gandhi’s book

Wait 5 sec.

Congress leader Sonia Gandhi’s critical references to Hindutva ideologue Vinayak Damodar Savarkar in her memoir, Belonging: A Journey of Love, have triggered a political backlash from the ruling Shiv Sena in Maharashtra. On Wednesday, taking serious objection to the references, Deputy Chief Minister Eknath Shinde’s Shiv Sena demanded the withdrawal of passages on pages 201 and 443 of the book and also sought a ban on its circulation in Maharashtra.In the 544-page memoir, formally launched in New Delhi on November 16, Gandhi, while reflecting on the Congress’s political history and its opposition to the Rashtriya Swayamsevak Sangh (RSS), refers to Savarkar’s mercy petitions to the British, a subject that has remained a point of political debate and polarisation.Advertisement“While Congress freedom fighters were enduring assaults and imprisonment at the hands of the British rulers, senior ideologues of the RSS like Vinayak Damodar Savarkar were writing mercy petitions to their colonial masters, and their members were colluding with the British authorities as informers,” Gandhi writes.In the same passage, she describes the RSS as having viewed the Congress and its values as the “primary stumbling block” in its design of a Hindu nation, with people of other faiths becoming second-class citizens. She also writes that the RSS’s chief ideologues had expressed admiration for Hitler and his policies concerning minorities.Also Read | Shinde Sena’s protest against Sonia book backfires after Bal Thackeray photo tornOn page 443, Gandhi contrasts Savarkar’s vision of Hindutva with the constitutional vision of India. She writes: “A contrary vision, articulated by Gandhiji’s contemporary Vinayak Damodar Savarkar, the founder of the ideology known as Hindutva, views India as primarily a nation where Hindus are supreme — an outlook espoused by the RSS, the BJP, and their numerous affiliates across the country known collectively as the ‘Sangh Parivar’, or ‘Family of the RSS’.”AdvertisementShe goes on to say that this ideology dismisses the constitutional rights of citizens as being opposed to the ethos of Hindu civilisation. She describes it as conservative, patriarchal and hierarchical, favouring the centralisation of power and wealth, and says this is what the BJP’s present leadership embodies.Savarkar’s association with the RSS is also a point of historical distinction. He was a prominent leader of the Hindu Mahasabha and served as its president from 1937 to 1943. The Hindu Mahasabha and the RSS were separate organisations, although Savarkar’s formulation of Hindutva became an influential strand of Hindu nationalist politics.Why is Savarkar a political issue in Maharashtra?For the Shiv Sena and BJP, Savarkar has long been an important symbol of Hindutva politics. Over the years, he has also become a potent political issue with which to corner the rival Shiv Sena (UBT), particularly after Uddhav Thackeray broke the alliance with the BJP and formed a government in Maharashtra with the Congress and the undivided NCP following the 2019 Assembly elections.Founded in 1966 around the demand for employment opportunities for Marathi-speaking people, the Shiv Sena increasingly embraced Hindutva in the 1980s. Its alliance with the BJP in 1989 consolidated this shift. Despite his father Prabodhnkar, being a critic of Savarkar, Bal Thackeray held the Hindutva ideologue in high regard politically.The Congress, meanwhile, has consistently opposed Savarkar’s political ideology. When his portrait was unveiled by then President A P J Abdul Kalam in Parliament’s Central Hall on February 26, 2003, the Congress and Left parties boycotted the event. Sonia Gandhi, then Congress president and Leader of the Opposition, had written to Kalam asking him not to attend the unveiling.Also Read | Savarkar row: Congress cites Bunch of Thoughts by Golwalkar to hit back at Shinde SenaThe following year, in August 2004, Bal Thackeray led the Sena’s “Jode Mara” agitation against then Union Petroleum Minister Mani Shankar Aiyar after the latter ordered the removal of a plaque bearing Savarkar’s poem at the Swatantrya Jyot near the Cellular Jail in Port Blair. The protest became a major political issue in Maharashtra ahead of that year’s Assembly elections.Uddhav Thackeray’s own public position on Savarkar was clear even before the formation of the Opposition Maha Vikas Aghadi (MVA) alliance. In September 2019, he demanded that Savarkar be conferred the Bharat Ratna and said Pakistan would not have come into existence had Savarkar been the Prime Minister at the time of the Partition.The differences between the Congress and the Sena over Savarkar surfaced soon after the MVA government was formed. In January 2020, a booklet distributed at a Congress-affiliated Seva Dal camp in Madhya Pradesh contained an insinuation about Savarkar’s relationship with Nathuram Godse. Shiv Sena MP Sanjay Raut reacted sharply, saying, “Veer Savarkar was a great man and will remain a great man.” In February 2020, the Maharashtra Congress’s Marathi publication Shidori carried articles criticising Savarkar’s record and ideology. These episodes exposed the ideological differences within the MVA even as the three parties continued to share power in the state.The faultline became central to the Sena split. In June 2022, Shinde led a rebellion against Uddhav, accusing him of compromising Bal Thackeray’s Hindutva politics by joining hands with the Congress and the undivided NCP. The Congress alliance was one of the central arguments used by the rebels to justify the split.The differences resurfaced after Rahul Gandhi criticised Savarkar over his mercy petitions during the Bharat Jodo Yatra in November 2022. In March 2023, following his disqualification from the Lok Sabha, Rahul said, “My name is not Savarkar. I am a Gandhi. I won’t apologise.”In response, Uddhav described Savarkar as his “idol” and said his insult would not be tolerated. He also cautioned Rahul against making remarks that could create divisions in the Opposition alliance.Also Read | From Sonia Gandhi’s ‘Belonging’ to Govind Pansare’s ‘Shivaji Kon Hota’: 8 books that shook Maharashtra politicsThe disagreement was serious enough for then NCP chief Sharad Pawar to step in as a mediator. After the March 2023 controversy, Pawar advised the Congress leadership to avoid further references to Savarkar. Rahul subsequently assured Sena (UBT) leader Sanjay Raut that he would refrain from making such remarks.Pawar, who now heads the NCP (SP), has otherwise adopted a more cautious position than the Congress, recognising Savarkar’s emotive connect among sections of Maharashtra’s electorate. At separate events in Nashik in 2021 and Nagpur in 2023, Pawar acknowledged aspects of Savarkar’s contribution, including his writing, poetry and scientific outlook, while clarifying that he did not endorse Savarkar’s ideology or that of the Hindu Mahasabha.Differences back to the forefrontThe controversy has brought these disagreements back to the forefront. On Thursday, Shiv Sena spokesperson Anand Paranjpe asked whether Uddhav would condemn Sonia Gandhi’s memoir and accused the Sena (UBT) chief of abandoning Bal Thackeray’s Hindutva. Paranjpe also asked Uddhav if he had forgotten that he had joined the 2004 protest against Aiyar.The Shiv Sena (UBT) has consistently responded to the BJP and the Shinde-led Sena by saying it does not require lessons on Hindutva from parties whose support for Savarkar is “restricted to electoral politics”. Raut said he had not read the entire memoir and questioned why BJP leader Nitesh Rane’s remarks on Savarkar were not being scrutinised.you may likeMaharashtra Congress spokesperson Atul Londhe has defended the passages in Gandhi’s memoir as factual, saying Savarkar’s grandson had acknowledged that he wrote a mercy petition. Londhe was also photographed presenting a copy of the memoir to Uddhav in the presence of Raut, which the Sena cited while questioning Uddhav’s position.On Thursday, Savarkar’s grandnephew Satyaki Savarkar said he was consulting his legal team and could initiate proceedings against Sonia Gandhi if the references were found to have no factual basis. He clarified that he had not read the entire book and was not seeking a ban at this moment.For Shinde, the controversy is an opportunity to question Uddhav’s association with the Congress and his claim to Bal Thackeray’s Hindutva legacy. For Uddhav, it underlines the tension between his own defence of Savarkar and the sharply different position of his allies.