Dear Rajinikanth sir, as a fan and an officer, ‘Jailer 2’ disturbed me

Wait 5 sec.

When Jailer 2 arrived on Prime Video, my husband and I knew how we would be spending our Saturday evening. Nothing was going to come between us and watching you.For those of us who grew up in South India in the ’80s, a Rajinikanth film was an occasion. We would spend weeks staring at the posters, imagining what the film might be about and then begin the difficult task of persuading our parents to take us. Then came the excitement of queuing for tickets and entering the darkened theatre, where your arrival on screen would be greeted with whistles, cheers and even coins and currency notes thrown towards the screen. In those pre-internet days, much of the happiness lay in the anticipation itself. Cinema was a rare treat, but you were something more.AdvertisementAlso Read | Rajinikanth at 50: From my mother to my nephew, there is a Rajini for everybodyThere is an interesting theory about our parents’ generation. They grew up watching, among others, N T Rama Rao, A Nageswara Rao, Sivaji Ganesan and Gemini Ganesan, who often played brooding heroes carrying the weight of the world on their shoulders. There was always a family to support, an injustice to correct or a country to save. Somehow, they even found time to romance the heroine, honourably of course. Perhaps our parents never quite learnt to relax because their heroes never did. Even happiness had to be earned through a suitable amount of suffering.Then came you, bringing a little irreverence and fun into this world of solemn, brooding heroes. You danced, made us laugh with your gravity-defying stunts and delivered dialogues we repeated for weeks afterwards. We were not innocent about cinema. Even as schoolchildren, we knew that your films required us to leave our reasoning outside the theatre. We obliged cheerfully and loved every minute of it. Years later, living in North India, we defended you against much teasing and I still sometimes mouth your dialogues with undiminished enthusiasm.Beneath all that fun, however, your films had a moral centre. Good prevailed over evil and doing the right thing mattered. As we entered public service, something of those films stayed with us. Not the dramatic speeches or the fights, but the quiet conviction that one must do what is right, even when it is inconvenient.AdvertisementCinema has moved on, with wonderful films about ordinary lives, complicated relationships and uncomfortable choices, alongside grand commercial entertainment. You have stayed with the familiar theme of good triumphing over evil, but surely that story can be told without making the world around the hero increasingly absurd. Jailer 2 asks rather too much of our old arrangement with you.In which part of India can so many people be killed without anyone thinking of calling the police? Where does the police force, along with practically the entire state machinery, exist only to serve the wrongdoers? What exactly are you suggesting about our institutions? Those of us who work in government know their shortcomings well enough. But there is a difference between showing failures within a system and imagining a world in which it might as well not exist. Surely even cinematic licence has its limits.More troubling is what all this violence is meant to establish. We understand that the hero is fighting for a good cause, but does that make everything he does in its name acceptable? The heroes we grew up admiring carried responsibilities. Here, the hero seems answerable to nobody. Once his cause is declared righteous, any amount of violence becomes permissible. If a good man must kill his way through every problem, what has become of the idea of doing good?you may likeThere was a time when your outrageous stunts made us laugh even as we applauded them. Now that playful absurdity seems to have given way to blood and gore. There is already enough violence and terror in the world around us that is deeply disturbing. Must our entertainment add to it in such extravagant detail? Even the impressive ensemble cast cannot keep Jailer 2 off the growing list of irresponsible cinema.You still look remarkable, and your screen presence has lost none of its charm. But why must you join the race to make ever more outlandish action films? There are enough stars across Bollywood, Tollywood, Kollywood and every other wood willing to fight 50 men at a time. Let them.I am no film critic and cannot presume to tell you what cinema should be. We admire you for continuing to act with such energy and enthusiasm and certainly don’t expect you to confine yourself to roles considered appropriate for your age. But you have spent a lifetime earning a place in our hearts that few actors can hope to occupy. Why risk turning yourself into a caricature of the hero we still admire?Respectfully,A lifelong admirerThe writer is an IRS officer. Views are personal