Noel has questioned the legal basis for the reappointment, including the relevant Articles of Association and the requirement for shareholder approval at a valid annual general meeting. (File Photo)Ahead of the crucial Tata Sons board meeting on November 26, Tata Trusts, led by Noel Tata, and the company’s board are digging in, with a flurry of demands and allegations from both sides. Tata Sons’ board may not accede to Noel Tata’s latest request, made for the third time on Friday, for audio-video recordings of its September 17 board meeting, at which N Chandrasekaran was reappointed chairman, sources said.In a fresh letter sent on Friday, Noel again sought the complete, unedited audio and video recordings of the board meeting, any transcript, and confirmation that the original recordings and their metadata had been preserved. He also demanded the final signed minutes or, if they remained unsigned, the revised draft showing which of his proposed corrections had been accepted and recording his dissent where they had not. He has sought a reply by November 25, a day before the board meeting.However, sources indicated that Tata Sons is unlikely to accede to Noel Tata’s request.Tata Sons did not respond to a mail from The Indian Express.Noel Tata’s demands also include the formal meeting notice, successive versions of the agenda, circulation dates and times, details of who instructed the changes, and the audit trail of documents uploaded to the board’s web application. He had also raised questions about transactions involving Hanno One Warehousing Private Limited, whose directors include Lalitha Chandrasekaran and Pranav Chandrasekaran, and its reported commercial relationship with TVS Motor.Also Read | Jimmy Tata: Why Ratan Tata’s reclusive brother is at odds with Noel TataIn a November 9 letter rejecting Noel Tata’s demand, company secretary Suprakash Mukhopadhyay said recordings were required only when directors attended meetings online and that the company had no practice of sharing recordings of in-person meetings. He added that such recordings did not need to be retained or shared with directors.Tata Sons said the draft minutes were uploaded on October 1 and amended following Noel’s response on October 8. The revised minutes would be placed before the board for confirmation. It also said the Registrar of Companies had been informed of the reappointment under Section 117 of the Companies Act within the stipulated 30-day period.Story continues below this adNoel has questioned the legal basis for the reappointment, including the relevant Articles of Association and the requirement for shareholder approval at a valid annual general meeting.Noel’s opposition centres on the proposed listing of Tata Sons following an RBI directive. He has argued that Chandrasekaran did not do enough to avert the listing. He has also raised concerns about the performance of investments in digital businesses, Air India and electronics during Chandrasekaran’s tenure, which began in 2017.While Tata Trusts nominee Venu Srinivasan supported the reappointment, Noel opposed it and walked out of the September 17 meeting at Bombay House. Tata Sons announced the resolution within an hour. The company also rejected allegations of a conflict of interest involving business dealings between the families of Chandrasekaran and Srinivasan.Also Read | Noel Tata pushes SP Group exit, restructuring proposals at Tata SonsAmid public exchanges of charges and counter-charges among trustees, a meeting of the Sir Dorabji Tata Trust (SDTT) on Friday saw a trustee appeal for restraint, saying the developments should not be allowed to damage the Tata brand.Story continues below this adThe trustee of SDTT is learnt to have raised the issue at the meeting and appealed for better sense to prevail, according to sources. Trustees Venu Srinivasan and Vijay Singh and former trustee Darius Khambata had sent a flurry of letters concerning various issues related to Tata Trusts and trustees.George Mathew is an Associate Editor with The Indian Express, based in Mumbai. A veteran of financia... Read More