Our real-life Khosla ka Ghosla: The honest salaried person is being pushed out

Wait 5 sec.

On November 11, Spain stopped work. In its first general strike in 14 years, millions walked out under the slogan “Salaries. Housing. Prices”. The estimated total participation was about 4 million, around one-fifth of the workforce. The strike gained momentum after a series of protests stirred by the eviction and subsequent death of an 87-year-old tenant in September. Protestors carried signs reading, “Not Even One More Maricarmen”.I have lived in Delhi all my life and can now be called the quintessential “Delhiwaali”. I have noticed how some definitive features of the real estate market sharpen their edge and become more exclusionary every year. The same story repeats itself in different hues in other metros today. In short, Spain has named the problem. India has not.AdvertisementAlso Read | Dis/Agree | From Satya Niketan tragedy, a takeaway: Student housing crisis needs private capitalFrom Do Bigha Zameen (1953) to Khosla Ka Ghosla (2006), Bombay cinema has told versions of this struggle for 70 years. We all know someone who has experienced it. From the farmer in India’s feudal past to the retired Delhi man who must save his plot from the new Zamindars, aka the broker-builder nexus, the Indian family has been fighting to own so they can live with dignity for a long time. The city changes, governments change, and the market only becomes more competitive and opaque. The struggle only gets worse.In India’s semi-regulated property market, a large part of any transaction still happens off the books in cash. But the biggest change since the 1980s and 1990s is not the NRI or the builder. It is what happened to the professional class itself. In the Delhi of the Eighties and Nineties, the doctor, the architect, and the lawyer were the professionals, the so-called “middle-class”. They were what we knew as the salaried professionals. They lived in government accommodation or in a DDA flat, and their status came from their profession, not their property portfolio. Today, many of these professionals live on their salary and also have a robust private consultancy. I know “salaried” professionals who have three DDA flats while they live in another.An average first-home buyer, a genuinely “salaried” person, is now competing with a doctor who is also a landlord, an architect who is also a speculator. On top of this came two new waves of money: The corporate class and the tech bros that rose after the IT boom. The outsourcing economy from the late 1990s to 2008 created a new kind of wealth, with salary jumps and ESOPs. Then came the startup boom from 2014 to 2021, when funding, exits, and secondary sales created overnight liquidity for a small, young group in Bangalore, Gurgaon and Delhi. All of that money, too, was parked in property. Not because these buyers needed three houses, but because in India, property has been the safest place to keep money that cannot be fully explained.AdvertisementFor a while, everyone has known that the real estate market is not designed for the person who only has the salary on her bank statement as income. No NRI dollars, no family property as leverage. Someone who desperately needs a house for their family is bidding against someone who does not need to live in the house, does not need a school nearby, and does not care if the flat stays empty for three years. And in between these stakeholders stands the broker. The powerful and least regulated actor in Indian real estate. Commission in India is market-determined, commonly around 1-2 per cent from each side in resale and remains negotiable. In practice, that means no fixed fee, no contract, no verifiable record that a buyer or seller can rely on.Delhi is a city that stopped planning for homes for a section of the population a while back. For years, we have lived in a gap, while the population kept growing. In most of Delhi, where jobs, schools and hospitals actually are, there has been almost no new DDA supply for decades.This is why Spain matters for India. Spain’s protesters are not asking for charity. They are asking a basic question: Is housing a place to live, or an asset to trade? In Spain, the Banco de España estimates a deficit of about 7,50,000 homes, set to grow to more than a million by 2028. In India, Knight Frank estimates an existing affordable urban housing shortage of 9.4 million units. We need legislation that finally asks three questions. How are you buying? Why are you buying? How many can you own? We need a clear legal distinction between a home for self-use and a property for investment.you may likeSecond, third and fourth homes should attract progressively higher stamp duty and higher property tax. We already do this for other assets. We need caps on the number of residential units one individual or family can hold in a city, and a vacancy tax on flats left empty for more than two years. Brokers must be brought fully under RERA, with a capped, published fee, a written mandate, and a digital receipt.In Delhi, the middle class is not protesting. Instead, it keeps quietly moving to the periphery, to Noida Extension, to Sonipat, to Bahadurgarh, to flats they did not want, in places they did not choose, paying EMIs for a life they did not wish for. That is not a housing market. That is an expulsion.If we want Delhi to remain a city where a person who earns honestly can live honestly, we have to stop treating housing as just another commodity. Spain has taken to the streets to say this. Delhi does not need to wait for its own November.Anubha Yadav is an academic, writer and filmmaker