The United States Supreme Court has docketed two cases involving the constitutionality of the Horseracing and Safety Integrity Act (HISA) for a Dec. 4 conference. The purpose of the conference is to determine whether the nation's highest will hear one, both, or neither of the cases in 2027.Lawsuits out of the Fifth and Sixth Circuits of the U.S. Court of Appeals both have pending “writ of certiorari” requests before the court. A writ of certiorari asks the Supreme Court to intervene in a case after all other forms of appeal within the federal court system have been exhausted.The Fifth Circuit case dates to 2021 and involves a lawsuit spearheaded by the National Horsemen's Benevolent and Protective Association (NHBPA).The Sixth Circuit case stems from a 2021 lawsuit led by the states of Oklahoma, West Virginia and Louisiana.A third case that is often grouped with the other two is still awaiting an appellate-level decision on a Supreme Court remand from 2025.That case, out of the Eighth Circuit and initiated in 2023 by executives with the Arkansas and Iowa HBPA affiliates, has not yet reached the certiorari stage a second time, like the two above-mentioned cases.A year and a half ago, the three cases out of the Fifth, Sixth and Eighth Circuits had all been appealed once via certiorari to the Supreme Court.In earlier rulings, the Fifth, Sixth and Eighth Circuit appeals courts had all agreed that HISA's rulemaking structure was constitutional. But the Fifth Circuit disagreed, in part, by opining that HISA's enforcement provisions were unconstitutional.Then, on June 30, 2025, the Supreme Court issued nearly identical “summary dispositions” for all three petitions involving the constitutionality of HISA, directing each appeals court to reconsider its HISA rulings in light of a relevant decision the Supreme Court had just issued on June 27, 2025.The Fifth and Sixth Circuits have since reaffirmed their earlier opinions. The Eighth Circuit has not yet ruled either way.Nearly 17 months after the Supreme Court's remand, there have been no significant entries on the Eighth Circuit's docket for the case since June 17.After Dec. 4, there is only one more conference date (Dec. 11) on the Supreme Court's calendar for 2026.According to the Supreme Court's website, the case distribution schedule “identifies the dates on which petitions for writs of certiorari, along with corresponding briefs in opposition and reply briefs, will be distributed to the Justices. It also identifies the dates on which those petitions are scheduled to be considered by the Justices at conference, although this schedule is subject to change.”Speaking on behalf of the Fifth Circuit case, Todd Mostoller, the executive director of the Pennsylvania Horsemen's Benevolent and Protective Association (PHBPA), updated commissioners during Tuesday's Pennsylvania Horse Racing Commission meeting about how the process would likely work.“That conference consists of just the nine justices, no staff, no clerk. They lock themselves in a room. They look at the potential cases that they will hear.“It's my understanding there's three things that can happen. One, they can agree to hear the case. Two, they can agree not to hear the case, which, at that point, it's dead. Or they can relist,” Mostoller said.“It's my understanding that most get relisted for further consideration. But [it] could be as early as Dec. 5 we have some clarity of whether the United States Supreme Court will hear the case,” Mostoller said.Exactly how the Supreme Court will handle the multiple writs filed by different petitioners is unclear at this point.But the fact that two of them have been grouped together for consideration on the same conference date raises the possibility that they could, in some way, be combined.The Supreme Court could choose to individually hear or decline to hear either case.Or, if it deems the questions of law are similar, the Supreme Court could decide to consolidate them into one larger case for the purpose of coming up with one common judgment that addresses all of the legal issues that have been raised.Another option is for the Supreme Court to reschedule the petitions for a conference at a later date, at which time the on-remand Eighth Circuit opinion could be known and/or included.The Sixth Circuit case has already been rescheduled once in recent months. It was originally listed for the Oct. 9 conference, but got pushed off of that date and was subsequently moved to Dec. 4.As the HISA Authority summed up in its Aug. 10, 2026, writ of certiorari, “All parties agree that the Fifth Circuit's outlier judgment warrants review. Given the intractable conflict over the facial constitutionality of HISA's enforcement provisions, only this Court can provide an authoritative nationwide ruling on that issue of legal and practical importance.”In response to that filing with the Supreme Court, Eric Hamelback, the NHBPA's chief executive officer, largely agreed that the Supreme Court needs to step in and make a decision.“We welcome Supreme Court review because this case is ultimately about something much bigger than HISA,” Hamelback said in an Aug. 19 response to the HISA filing. “It is about the constitutional limits on government power and whether Congress can give a private organization the authority to investigate, prosecute, adjudicate and impose penalties on American horsemen without meaningful federal supervision.”The post Supreme Court to Consider Two HISA Cases Dec. 4 appeared first on TDN | Thoroughbred Daily News | Horse Racing News, Results and Video | Thoroughbred Breeding and Auctions.