Should I snitch on my sister's boyfriend and disrupt his OCIA process?

Wait 5 sec.

I apologize if this post breaks rules. I initially posted this in r/Catholicism but the post was removed, and this doesn't fit the other suggested subreddits. I'm looking for guidance on what to do and not asking if these actions are sins, but if it breaks the rules nonetheless, please feel free to remove it. My sister is getting serious with her boyfriend of a year and a half. He's a wonderful guy who, although he isn't Christian, plays in the band as she cantors every Sunday evening at one of our nearby churches. She really wants him to get baptized so that she can have a full Catholic wedding Mass with a Eucharistic celebration when she marries him. He's been resistant because even though he supports her musical efforts within the church, he refuses to believe in God. This has been a strained point of contention between the two of them, and my sister has told him that if he doesn't go through this process and deprives her of a Catholic wedding mass, she'll resent him for it for the rest of her life. Eventually, they came to a compromise: he'll go through the OCIA process and publicly profess that he believes these things for the sake of giving my sister her desired wedding, even though he won't personally believe in God. My sister is ecstatic with this decision. Even though she sings every week, she doesn't take her faith very seriously; on weekends where she doesn't sing, she doesn't attend mass. She doesn't comply with other practices, such as Lenten Friday abstinence, and views many sins as non-binding suggestions, so her boyfriend not truly believing doesn't pose a significant impediment in her eyes. My parents are also content with this thought process; they believe that it's unrealistic to actually expect someone to change their beliefs, and if my sister's boyfriend undergoes this process as described, my parents don't have to suffer the "shame" of telling their friends and family that my sister is marrying someone not Catholic. (Not sure if it matters, but my parents also don't attend Sunday mass regularly) I'm the only one in my family who feels concerned about this. To my knowledge, no one outside of my family knows of his intentions to lie about his faith. I sincerely hope and pray that God will soften his heart such that if he gets baptized, there will be some inkling of faith that will make a baptism genuine. But if not, I'm torn as to whether I should say something or keep quiet. Part of me wants to defend the integrity of the sacraments and prevent people from knowingly defrauding the church. But if I do say something to the priest or OCIA director, my family will know that it came from me, my sister will potentially resent me for "depriving" her of the wedding mass she wants, and my parents will be frustrated with me for putting them in a more socially awkward position. I'm having trouble internally justifying damaging the relationship with my family over something that seems more and more legalistic. I really appreciate your wisdom, especially because I don't know if I'm making a much bigger deal out of this than it really is.   submitted by   /u/LostMedallion   to   r/AskAPriest [link]   [comments]