The Thurgood Marshall U.S. Courthouse in Manhattan, home of the U.S. Court of Appeals for the Second Circuit. (Photo: U.S. General Services Administration) If you have a New York City carry license, you can carry exactly one handgun at a time, and you can buy exactly one handgun every 90 days. On Nov. 10, a federal appeals court put challenges to both rules back in play.Nothing changes on the street yet. Both limits stay in force while the case goes back to the trial court, where New York City now has to show they fit the nation's historical tradition of gun regulation. If it can't, they could fall. No deadline was set.The ruling came from a three-judge panel of the U.S. Court of Appeals for the Second Circuit, which hears appeals from federal courts in New York, Connecticut and Vermont. The panel was careful to say it wasn't calling the rules "necessarily unconstitutional," only that the city has to defend them on history. A challenge to the city's licensing fees didn't make it.Who suedThree men filed Mills v. New York City in August 2022:Charles Mills of Queens holds a city carry license. He wants to carry a backup handgun, and he says the 90-day rule kept him from buying a Glock at a Queens gun shop.Craig Sotomayor of Nassau County has a state carry license plus the special city license for nonresidents.Braden Holliday of the Bronx says he can't afford the $340 application fee, the $88.50 fingerprinting fee or the $340 renewal every three years.U.S. District Judge Jed S. Rakoff dismissed the suit in December 2024.Where the trial judge went wrongRakoff tossed the carry limit, the 90-day rule and the fee claim at step one of the test from New York State Rifle & Pistol Association v. Bruen, the Supreme Court's 2022 decision recognizing a right to carry a handgun in public for self-defense. Step one asks whether the Second Amendment's plain text covers what the plaintiff wants to do. If it does, the burden shifts to the government at step two to justify the rule with history.Judge Reena Raggi, writing for the panel, said the carry limit and the 90-day rule both clear step one. The amendment protects the right to keep and bear "Arms," plural, and "does not place a numerical limit on this right." A rule designed to slow down gun purchases does "meaningfully constrain" that right.The city pointed out that founding-era guns were single-shot and had to be reloaded by hand after every shot. The panel wasn't convinced that helps the city, but either way, it's a historical argument, and it belongs at step two. Same for the city's claim that the 90-day rule deters straw buyers, people who buy guns to pass them illegally to someone else. "Perhaps so," the court wrote, but that's for step two too.The panel also revived a narrower claim over the city's old cap of two handguns registered to a carry license. The city repealed that cap in August 2024 and no longer sets a strict limit, so all that's left is Mills's claim for past damages.What stays dismissedThe fee claim ran into Kwong v. Bloomberg, a 2013 Second Circuit decision upholding these same fees. Under Kwong, a licensing fee is fine if it covers administrative costs without exceeding them and doesn't impose more than a marginal burden. The panel said Holliday's own fee claim was too conclusory to survive anyway.Challenges to three other rules stay dismissed because no plaintiff showed he'd been personally injured by them, which you need for standing to sue:the requirement to get authorization before buying a handgunthe rule that every handgun be registered to a licensethe dealer-reporting part of the 90-day ruleWhat's nextRakoff had already predicted the revived claims would "likely fail" at step two. The panel called that remark "more suggestive than conclusory" and wants an actual historical analysis before anyone decides. Either side could also ask the full Second Circuit to rehear the case en banc, or go to the Supreme Court.