Observing that the needs of a child with disabilities cannot be treated as ordinary personal hardship and that the bank’s caregiver policy must be given due consideration, the Rajasthan High Court has asked Bank of Baroda to reconsider the transfer of a manager whose 13-year-old daughter has 45 per cent intellectual disability and dyslexia. The manager cited the need to ensure continuity in his daughter’s schooling, therapy and care.Justice Kuldeep Mathur was hearing a petition filed by Gowardhan Singh, a chief manager with Bank of Baroda, challenging the order dated September 24, 2026, insofar as it concerned his posting. Singh sought reconsideration of his placement in the Banaskantha region of Gujarat, citing his daughter’s disability-related requirements.“The circumstances relating to the petitioner’s minor daughter, particularly her certified 45 per cent Intellectual Disability, Dyslexia and the need for continuity of education, therapy and family support, cannot be treated as an ordinary ground of personal hardship…An administrative decision concerning the posting of a parent who is the caregiver of such a child, therefore, deserves consideration which is sensitive to these circumstances and cannot be approached as a routine request for transfer founded merely upon personal convenience,” the court observed on November 17.The court examined the matter in the context of the Rights of Persons with Disabilities Act, 2016, and the bank’s March 29, 2019, circular providing for consideration of employees caring for dependants with specified disabilities for exemption from routine or rotational transfers, subject to administrative constraints.Transfer from Jodhpur to MumbaiAccording to the petition, Singh was initially posted in the Jodhpur Zone. Through a transfer order and email dated May 18, 2026, he was transferred to the bank’s Baroda Corporate Centre in Mumbai. He was relieved on May 22 and joined in Mumbai on May 25. Justice Kuldeep Mathur observed that the needs of a child with disabilities extend beyond schooling to continuity of therapeutic support, care and an enabling family environment. (Image enhanced using AI)His daughter, aged about 13, has been certified as having 45 per cent intellectual disability. The order also records that she faces difficulties relating to speech, communication, reading and writing. After joining Mumbai, Singh and his family made efforts to secure suitable schooling and ensure continuity of care and therapeutic support for the child. He subsequently submitted representations to the bank authorities on July 14 and July 24, 2026, explaining the circumstances arising from his daughter’s disability.On August 18, he furnished alternative posting options, including Jodhpur, Jaipur, Ludhiana, Chandigarh, New Delhi and Banaskantha. He also drew the bank’s attention to a Credit Head vacancy at its regional office in Bikaner and requested consideration for posting against that position.Story continues below this adOn September 25, Singh submitted an application seeking reversal of his promotion, if required, and made a detailed representation to the bank‘s Executive Director in the Human Resources Management Department. He was subsequently transferred to Ahmedabad Zone and posted in the Banaskantha region.Bank’s caregiver policySingh relied on Bank of Baroda’s circular dated March 29, 2019, which provides for consideration of employees caring for dependants with specified disabilities for exemption from routine or rotational transfers, subject to administrative constraints.His counsel argued that although the bank had framed a specific policy recognising the circumstances of such employees, Singh’s case had not been meaningfully considered under it. The high court emphasised that the purpose of the policy would be defeated if administrative constraints were cited without objectively examining the available alternatives.“In the opinion of this Court, the object of such a policy would stand defeated if the mere existence of administrative constraints were to result in the disability-related circumstances being reduced to a routine transfer request, without an objective examination of the available alternatives,” Justice Mathur observed.Story continues below this adThe court said the competent authority was expected to undertake meaningful and compassionate consideration of the case, keeping in view the disability rights legislation, the bank’s caregiver-related policy and the child’s educational and therapeutic requirements. The high court also referred to the Rights of Persons with Disabilities Act, 2016, which embodies the legislative commitment to dignity, equality, inclusion and effective participation of persons with disabilities.Disposing of the petition, the high court granted Singh liberty to submit a fresh and comprehensive representation before the competent bank authority, along with relevant supporting documents. It directed the authority to objectively consider the nature and extent of his daughter’s disability, her educational and therapeutic requirements, the applicable bank policy and administrative exigencies.“The competent authority is, therefore, expected to undertake a meaningful and compassionate consideration of the petitioner’s case, keeping in view the statutory philosophy underlying the Rights of Persons with Disabilities Act, 2016, the Bank‘s own caregiver-related policy and the educational and therapeutic requirements of the minor child,” the court said.The bank must decide the representation through a reasoned order, in accordance with law, within six weeks from the date of receiving it.