The Hunger Games: Sunrise on the Reaping Review – Viva La Revolution

Wait 5 sec.

It’s some strange twist of the Hollywood Fates that President Snow became such a compelling baddie in the halls of franchise cinema. Within the pages of Suzanne Collins’ first Hunger Games novel, he wasn’t quite there on arrival. He served the purpose of a dystopian YA book’s autocrat, but the pampered, even foppish philosopher’s fiend in cream-colored suits? That came along after Collins saw the Lionsgate films and entered a creative feedback loop with the movie series that continues to pay rewarding dividends. Also casting the likes of Donald Sutherland as the creepy bastard will always be a boon, and in this case setting an acting precedent that the series continues to meet and build on.So it is a decade and several recasts later, as we trapeze back and forth along Panem’s timeline like a Christopher Nolan astronaut, that we find our hated dictator now inhabited by Ralph Fiennes for a handful of scenes in The Hunger Games: Sunrise on the Reaping. The elegant English thesp so gently, so happily underplays the banality of evil, the menace of cordial, moral indifference, that even the pregnant pauses between his condescensions speak volumes. It’s a trick that will compound for longtime fans who remember the character’s youth with that Covey girl of District 12, or his future doom at the hands of another daughter of Appalachia.cnx.cmd.push(function() {cnx({playerId: "106e33c0-3911-473c-b599-b1426db57530",}).render("0270c398a82f44f49c23c16122516796");});This ever-growing richness of Collins’ mythology and worldbuilding five books and six movies in is a testament to her imagination. When stories as brash, grandiose, and if we’re being honest, a little bit silly in their soapiness, as these can command this level of nuance, it speaks to something thoughtful at the core of the Hunger Games. It’s a foundational quality that deserves more flowers than it often receives from critics.Not that there aren’t plenty of flowers—or things to be critical of—in Sunrise on the Reaping. The arena of the Second Quarter Quell from which the film earns its name (i.e. the 50th annual Hunger Games) is so bespoke in pastel blossoms and saturated mountain colors, nestled here along a Bavarian-looking meadow, that even Julie Andrews might lower her gaze while searching for her sunglasses. Such bucolic scenery is of course a come-on, a deceptive trap to conceal murderous foliage, as well as feral wildlife where the butterflies have fangs. It is here that Snow is pulling out all the stops for a big birthday bash of Hunger Games carnage, and where the stage is set for the tragic backstory of Haymitch Abernathy (Joseph Zada), the future burned-out and bitter Hunger Games survivor inhabited by Woody Harrelson in the original movies. Harrelson was so good at leaning into the character’s misanthropy that it feels almost scandalous to learn there was a time when he was as cocky and lovelorn as Jennifer Lawrence’s Katniss, and also a moment where he too dreamed of lighting the fire of rebellion.In many ways, Sunrise on the Reaping is a back to basics approach for its franchise, returning squarely to the melodramatic life-and-death stakes inside the arena for the first time since 2013’s Catching Fire. (The interluding films were about war, revolution, or the unsettling portrait of descending into fascism via the Snow-fixated Songbirds and Snakes.) Indeed, Sunrise includes all those beats that more recent entries omitted or glossed over: the titular reaping where two tributes/human sacrifices are selected from the child population of each district (this time it’s four kids, because 50th!); the vacuous interviews with a sycophantic talk show host (Kieran Culkin subbing in as a young Stanley Tucci); and even the faint hints of a love triangle between the rascally young Haymitch, the girl he left behind, Lenore Dove (Whitney Peak), and the one he is meeting on death’s door, Maysilee Donner (Mckenna Grace).Yet it is more than the trappings of a now quite familiar formula that make Sunrise on the Reaping endearing. In fact, it is the layers it can lean on from its almost obscene wealth of acting talent, and the genuinely bittersweet hard truths that Collins and director Francis Lawrence are trying to instill in this candy-colored franchise, which makes Sunrise worthwhile. It’s the straight line from Sutherland to Fiennes, or Jennifer Lawrence to Zada and Grace, that reminds viewers this is a series with big ideas in its head and blood in its mouth.A lot of that fresh blood comes from the talent onscreen. Zada perhaps wisely only bothers impersonating Woody Harrelson in the scenes where Haymitch is “turning it on” for the cameras, such as his forced sit-down interview witha reality TV host. In those moments, Zada’s benign hint of a Southern accent turns into Harrelson’s Texas bravado, but by virtue of creating a distinction between the Haymitch we think we know and the more sensitive, yearning kid Zada plays when alone suggests deeper waters running beneath our protagonist.Grace is similarly compelling as the secondary lead. Essentially playing a proto-Katniss Everdeen, Grace’s Maysilee is world-weary at 17, standoffish, and perhaps doomed to stand in Lawrence’s shadow. But the young actor has enough charisma to make the character’s arc carry a gravitas  beyond her years. At one point, Maysilee talks about how more than anything, maintaining her dignity during the games is her ultimate goal. That’s a quality Grace brings in spades.Still, a lot of the movie belongs to the starry walk-ons that hover somewhere between cameos and genuine supporting work. A few of them admittedly feel a bit too much like mugging in the margins, a la Culkin, but some find subtle ways to suggest tangible humanity in a couple of minutes, such as Elle Fanning as a deeply humane Effie Trinket (Elizabeth Banks down the road), who in her youth is still acutely in touch with her empathy. Others meanwhile are allowed to carry the real heart of the movie, as is the case with Jesse Plemons as a young Plutarch, the cunning Capitol politico who knows how to wine and dine the rich and powerful, but beneath his suave veneer holds the aspirations of a revolutionary. There is nothing scenery-chewing or broad about Plemons’ quietly intelligent choices. Instead they’re informed by what reads as a desperate hunger for change.It is that theme about resistance, and the cost of political dissent, that gives Sunrise a soul. As aforementioned, the film is going a bit through the motions of the first two books/films in the Katniss saga. In fact, the movie is at its weakest in a prolonged first act when certain elements—like the reaping or District 12’s costume faux pas courtesy of a way-too-hammy Billy Porter—suggest Francis Lawrence is walking through his paces after directing four of the last five Hunger Games movies. The emotional devastation of when Katniss endured these same indignities, or Rachel Zegler’s Lucy Gray wasn’t even treated with the pretense of civility, is muted on the third go-round. The also much publicized cameo by Jennifer Lawrence in this film is the definition of franchise obligation and tacked on.But whatever issues arise from the dangers of IP repetition and diminishing returns are alleviated by a film and source material that is still illuminated by a tangible anger. There’s no denying the sort of idiocracy Collins first wrote about in 2008 has become a lot less farfetched or abstract in the past 18 years. But where that initial cycle of stories was more of a warning about the danger of distraction and finding entertainment in folks’ suffering, Collins’ later prequels have become far blunter and fiery in their inclinations.Sunrise on the Reaping thus acts as an adolescent-friendly treatise about not losing hope in the face of an ugly and worsening world; an encouragement to stay engaged and avoid jaded apathy, even when realizing the horrors outside your window might outlive you. It’s a four-quadrant clarion call to keep marching. That it delivers this in a format that is as broadly appealing, and at times heartbreaking, a movie as this is its own kind of act of Hollywood rebellion.The Hunger Games: Sunrise on the Reaping opens on Friday, Nov. 20.The post The Hunger Games: Sunrise on the Reaping Review – Viva La Revolution appeared first on Den of Geek.