Man City sanctions facing major delay with punishment this season now touch and go

Wait 5 sec.

Any sanctions for Manchester City could be subject to a lengthy delay with at least two further hearings expected if their appeal fails.That’s according to football finance expert Stefan Borson as the club wait to fight their case against the guilty verdict imposed on them in September by an independent commission.A hearing into City’s appeal against their guilty verdict of financial charges will be held in DecemberGettyCity have been found guilty on all charges in relation to financial rule breaches in the Premier League from 2009 to 2018, which includes the artificial inflation of their revenue by £900million in that period.An appeal has been launched and its hearing is set to take place next month, although any possible sanctions are expected to be handed down to City in 2027 if they are unsuccessful.The club claim to have a ‘comprehensive body of irrefutable evidence’ that supports them in their case.Premier League rivals have called for any sanctions to be applied this season but, as Borson explained on White and Jordan for talkSPORT, this is not guaranteed.What is the latest on City’s appeal hearing?Borson said: “My understanding is that there has been no sanction hearing, so it’s not as if the hearing has taken place with the independent commission but they’re holding back the release of the decision, it’s just that they haven’t yet sat down and had the pitching of their cases, that will come after the appeal.“So that looks like one of the uncertainties that we had about the process has now been cleared up. We’ll have the appeal in December, it will definitely be days. “The question is whether it’ll be five, ten days. If it is starting on the 12th, let’s say, of December, which is probably the last day it could start if it’s mid-December, there’s not a big window there because people are not working after about the 23rd in the legal world.“There’s probably only five to ten days that it could take for an appeal which is fairly short, I think, for an appeal of this magnitude, and certainly points to there being limited, if any, new evidence and no re-hearing of any witness evidence. “So what they’ll be doing is going through legal arguments and barrister submissions in respect of what’s in that very big document that we haven’t seen: the unredacted decision.”When asked about a timeframe for possible sanctions to be revealed or imposed, Borson explained: “So, we’ll have the hearing. It’s then unclear under the rules, because we don’t know which rulebook we’re working to. Borson has warned that there could be further hearings to come as part of the appeal process against sanctionsAFP“But let’s say 30 to 45 days, I think pretty much minimum, before we get a decision of the appeal. Now, the appeal usually would take much longer to give its decision, usually months, but it may be that the parties have agreed some kind of expedited decision, just to try and squeeze this all into this season. “At that point the Premier League or City, probably City, decide to challenge aspects of the appeal decision under Rule X arbitration.“Now, there’s only very limited ways in which they could do that, but that could again set up another hearing, probably with another 30-day delay before the hearing starts, then the hearing itself, and then another delay for a decision from that Rule X hearing, which may follow. “Only at that stage could City challenge anything at the High Court level, and even then it’s only on very limited grounds. “The point I’m trying to make is that a lot of the speed of the sanction, if City are unsuccessful on appeal, depends on whether they end up appealing under Rule X and whether the timetable has to shift out further, awaiting decisions.”On whether City will know their fate this season, he added: “I think it’s going to be touch and go now. It will depend… let’s say City lose the appeal and decide they have no grounds to challenge anything about the appeal.Whilst City are unlikely to be fully successful in their appeal, some aspects of the charges could be challengedGetty“In that scenario, we probably will move quite quickly to the first stage of the sanction, which is the independent commission who, clearly, are very against City, we know that from the thousand pages or whatever it is that they’ve written up, so they are going to come in very hard on City. “City then will appeal the sanction. It’s very unlikely the Premier League would but City will appeal the sanction. I think in almost any scenario, City will appeal the sanction. So, at very least, if City lose the appeal on liability from December, there’s still two hearings remaining.”What could City be successful in appealing?Although Borson believes City have a low chance of being completely successful in their appeal, he pointed out which charges they may be able to challenge as he said: “I think they may pick off the big bits, that’s what they’re going to try and do, definitely. “They have definitely got a good chance, I think, in relation to the UEFA charges, which don’t look right because the Premier League has not gone after all of the teams that breach UEFA – Aston Villa, Chelsea, everybody else – so it does look like they may have overreached there.“City may succeed on this designation of a sham, but then there is a fallback position because the independent commission have got an alternative case on that. “So, I think City are more likely to pick off bits. Let’s say City did win on everything… look, the parties are at war, I think. We see that from some of the press yesterday.”Premier League makes plea to rival clubsAs per The Times, the Premier League have asked clubs to provide legal protection for chief executive Richard Masters and four other board directors should City sue them.On this, Borson commented: “Ordinarily, companies would say to their directors, ‘Don’t worry about being sued, we’ll pay, so unless you’ve done something seriously wrong…’Premier League clubs have been asked to offer legal support for Masters and his colleagues if City decide to sueGetty“Obviously if it’s a criminal thing or if it’s an FCA (Financial Conduct Authority) sanction, they won’t pay for things like that, but if it’s for ordinary course, somebody didn’t like the actions that you took in business, usually the company would pay. “It turns out that somehow the Premier League, like the EFL (English Football League) have got a very old style indemnity within their articles of association which are the rules of the company association. “And it means that in theory, the directors are exposed personally to pay defence costs if they’re sued personally by a third party, and that could include Etihad or Etisalat in this situation.”