A flight ticket cancellation query in July 2023 ended up costing a Hyderabad-based software engineer and his sister Rs 4.53 lakh in a cyber fraud. More than three years later, a Telangana Consumer Commission has directed the bank to pay the engineer Rs 4.16 lakh holding that the bank failed to establish that he had knowingly shared his banking credentials with the fraudsters.The Ranga Reddy District Consumer Disputes Redressal Commission, comprising president Chitneni Latha Kumari and members D Madhavi Latha and Kathyayani Khandavilli, was hearing K Chandra Shekar Prasad’s complaint alleging that the bank had failed to prevent unauthorised transactions worth Rs 4.06 lakh, opened a salary overdraft account without his knowledge and failed to act promptly after he reported the cyber fraud. The relief by the commission covers his own Rs 4.06 lakh loss. His sister’s separate Rs 47,000 loss was not adjudicated in these proceedings.“Nothing [was] brought before this Commission that the complainant knowingly disclosed the sensitive information such as Password, OTP, MPIN and card number to the fraudsters…Hence, the Opposite Parties (the bank and its officials) contention that the complainant and her sister shared the screen, OTPs, credentials and parameters and installed the Any Desk of which gave access to the fraudsters into the mobile of the complainant, is not tenable in the absence of any such conclusive cyber crime investigation report.,” the commission said on October 28.The complaint, filed on May 6, 2024, arose from an incident on July 4, 2023, when Prasad and his sister were trying to cancel a flight ticket and obtain a flight ticket cancellation refund. Their online search for customer-care numbers allegedly brought them in contact with fraudsters.How fraud unfoldedThe bank alleged that the siblings installed a remote-access android application to cancel a flight ticket allowing access to their phones. Prasad disputed that he knowingly shared confidential credentials. The order records that Rs 98,503 was transferred from Prasad’s savings account and another Rs 3.08 lakh through a salary overdraft account opened in his name. His sister separately lost Rs 47,000, taking their combined loss to Rs 4.53 lakh. Prasad alleged that the overdraft account had been opened without his knowledge or informed consent.Prasad said the transactions took place between 3.45 pm and 4.15 pm and that he contacted the bank within half an hour. The bank acknowledged his complaint by SMS at 5.38 pm, saying a dispute had been registered and an interim credit processed for the disputed savings-account transaction. He alleged that the bank informed the beneficiary banks only around 7.32 pm and 7.36 pm. The bank maintained that it had sent communications to them on the same day.The bank said the transactions were authenticated through its mobile pay application using credentials including OTPs and PINs. It also said the overdraft facility required authentication using debit-card grid details. Relying on the RBI’s July 6, 2017, circular on customer liability in unauthorised electronic transactions, the bank argued that customers who compromise credentials must bear the loss until they report the fraud. It maintained that it could not independently freeze accounts held with other banks without directions from authorities or a court.Story continues below this adNegligence was not establishedReferring to Gauhati High Court observations later left undisturbed by the Supreme Court, the commission said banks must establish customer negligence through reliable material; an allegation of credential-sharing alone is insufficient.It noted that the bank’s investigation report recorded- “there is no IMPS I-mobile Activation during the misuse period. Hence, the case is closed as ‘inconclusive’.” The commission said the bank had not produced conclusive evidence that Prasad or his sister knowingly shared passwords, OTPs, MPINs or card details.It held that Prasad was entitled to reimbursement under clauses 8 and 9 of the RBI circular. It also rejected the bank’s objection that criminal proceedings prevented it from hearing the consumer complaint, observing that a customer could separately seek relief for deficiency in service.The commission partly allowed the complaint and directed the two opposite parties, jointly and severally, to refund Rs 4.06 lakh with 6 per cent annual interest from May 6, 2024, the date of filing, until realisation. It also ordered Rs 10,000 towards litigation costs.Story continues below this adTakeawayIf you fall victim to an online banking fraud, report it to your bank immediately and preserve all complaint acknowledgements and transaction records. A bank cannot automatically blame you for sharing credentials. It must establish customer negligence with reliable evidence before denying liability for unauthorised transactions.Aggrieved consumers may contact the consumer helpline in their respective states (Telangana: 0771-2582902) or call the National Consumer Helpline at 1915 for assistance.Don’t miss out on these stories:Son dies weeks after insurance policy revival, LIC to pay Rs 9 lakh to father after 3 yearsRe 1 refund sent to wallet instead of bank account, retailer ordered to pay Rs 7,500Airline changes paid seats last minute, passenger wins Rs 34,000 consumer relief