You wouldn’t think a beverage order would rank among a sci-fi franchise’s memorable moments, but “tea, Earl Grey, hot” is one of Star Trek’s most iconic lines. Of course, it helps that Captain Picard’s tea is produced by one of the most glorious — or befuddling — pieces of tech in all of sci-fi. Star Trek’s replicator, which can promptly materialize food and drink out of thin air, looms large in the series and in the minds of the viewers.Anyone who’s watched the replicator in action has dreamed of summoning tea (or nachos) on command. It’s not as glamorous as the warp engine, but it just might be as important. “The replicator... is often read as an iteration of the show about globalization, late-20th-century abundance, and a liberal democratic/capitalist hegemony,” says Stephen Dyson, a University of Connecticut political science professor. So while it usually serves a background role on-screen, there’s a strong argument to be made that the replicator is the most life-changing scientific advancement in the fictional universe.Captain Picard enjoys another glass of replicated tea. | CBS/ParamountThe (Questionable) Science Behind the ReplicatorEven in a franchise full of scientific miracles, the replicator is perhaps the most miraculous. The replicator weaves energy into matter faster than someone can say “Crunchwrap Supreme.” On-screen, the replicator is limited only by vague restraints on complexity, the need for a power source, and the current demands of the plot. You would essentially have to set off a nuclear warhead every time you wanted tomato soup, and you’d need a second bomb for the bowl.You can’t replicate a living creature, for example, and if you want a Thanksgiving dinner for 20, you’ll have to replicate it piece by piece. Beyond that, you can not only program a specific cheesecake recipe, but the replicator will build it out of healthy ingredients while still making it taste decadent. Are we anywhere close to having such remarkable technology? In terms of converting energy into matter, no. Not at all. The laws of physics just aren’t on our side. In order to pull off this physics trick, you would essentially have to set off a nuclear warhead every time you wanted tomato soup, and you’d need a second bomb for the bowl. The fictional engines that power the Federation make our power grid look like a motley collection of turnspit dogs, but even Trek’s high-tech society is stretching the limits of physical reality here. In fact, the real scientific implausibility of the replicator is that it’s essentially the same technology as Trek’s famous transporter: converting matter to energy. But whereas the transporter converts matter to energy and back to matter, the replicator is vaguer: It seems that we’re dealing with both unlimited energy and unlimited matter.Asking for some linguine would blow out San Fransico’s power grid today. | CBS/ParamountReplicated AbundanceEarlier versions of replicators — protein resequencers on Enterprise, then food synthesizers on The Original Series — functioned more like advanced food printers. They were limited in output and flavor profile, so they supplemented on-board chefs rather than replacing them. Still, the resequencer appears in the Trek timeline shortly before the Federation itself, so freedom from privation has always been an attractive reason to sign up.“Federation membership had lots of benefits, and access to replicator technology would be a big one.”“The Federation by Picard's time is a polity of abundance,” says Dyson, co-host of The Pop Culture Professors on YouTube. It’s “maybe a bit like the European Union at its most prosperous. Federation membership had lots of benefits, and access to replicator technology would be a big one.”A punchcard powered food synthesizer from The Original Series. | CBS Photo Archive/CBS/Getty ImagesStill, even endless food doesn’t mean endless peace; ambitious conquerors like the Klingons and the Dominion didn't stop waging battle on ideological grounds just because the Federation could whip up a decent replicated soufflé. On the other hand, food still plays a diplomatic role in the future. Just look at the Next Gen episode where Riker eats a writhing mass of gagh to impress his Klingon hosts.“In Star Trek's post-scarcity society, people do things for self and collective improvement rather than material need or gain,” Dyson says. “Strictly unnecessary things are still done because they have human meaning. Riker plays the trombone, for example. Cooking for a group would likely retain that role. To get very current, AI can produce competent text with no human effort. Yet I don't see many people excited to read an AI-produced novel. The human touch — the sense of a figurative handshake between two human consciousnesses — still means something, and likely always will.”So it’s no wonder that Star Trek often shows its characters eating together when they could all be wolfing down some replicated mac and cheese in their quarters. But just what would food mean to people in a replicator-filled future?Delicious? No. Diplomatic? For sure. | CBS/ParamountWhy Cooking Will Always MatterFor a franchise where no one needs to know how to cook, many characters still love doing it. Sisko cooks for his command staff on Deep Space Nine, while his father runs a Cajun restaurant on Earth. Neelix uses his culinary skills to raise spirits on Voyager, and Picard oversees an entire vineyard even though “synthehol” is readily available. Then there’s Captain Pike. “Many Star Trek characters love food, but especially Captain Pike,” artist Janice Poon tells Inverse. “He has a great love of cooking to the extent that he brings his own knives onboard, and through his careful preparation of meals, he shows the depth of his nurturing response to his crew’s needs.”Captain Pike offers a triumphant hunk of meat. | ParamountPoon’s work includes food styling on shows like Hannibal, Foundation, Star Trek: Discovery, and Strange New Worlds. Food, Poon says, offers a “silent script” that “reflects the personalities of the diners while giving clues about their motivations and desires.”“In one scene, Pike grills an elaborate barbecue for the crew — the quintessential team-building meal ever since Neanderthals’ post-hunt celebrations with their clans,” Poon says. “I used large cuts of meat, including dino ribs, on the Enterprise's grill to reinforce that concept. In another scene, Pike plans a seduction with bread, wine, and pasta. Nothing difficult to eat (so as not to complicate the proceedings), nor hard to digest (to keep blood flowing to the right places). He makes his intentions clear as he strokes the cheese over the zester.”“In a Star Trek future where replicators provide our meals instantly, we may find ourselves just as dissatisfied as we are today by any meal mixed from powders and emulsions.”You wouldn’t impress a date by taking premade Walmart lasagna out of the oven, so home-cooked food will always offer a personal touch. And even if you’re not socializing, you might cook for your own sense of satisfaction. Yesterday’s necessities become tomorrow’s hobbies; no one in the developed world needs to can food to survive winter anymore, but canning has become popular because people find it satisfying to engage with the process.Plus, you don’t have to worry about technical issues. | CBS/Paramount“In a Star Trek future where replicators provide our meals instantly, we may find ourselves just as dissatisfied as we are today by any meal mixed from powders and emulsions,” Poon says. “An instant meal may supply adequate nutrition, flavor, and texture, but it cannot provide emotional value. So even in a world rife with replicators, the hand-made meal will endure. A replicator doesn’t have imagination and doesn’t understand generosity and nostalgia, which comprise much of a recipe’s value.”Poon even posits that, if replicators were real, an old-fashioned kitchen with fresh ingredients would become a status symbol for the rich, much like having a private chef is a wealth marker today. People with lots of spare time and money tend to make food more complicated, while eschewing fast food and microwave dinners. A replicator can create what you ask of it, but it can’t create an experience.“Humans have communicated with food even before we had language: caring, bribing, encouraging, seducing, healing... with a thoughtfully prepared dish,” Poon says. “In the future, we might find ourselves leaning into food offerings to get our point across. Will we use replicators as our lingua franca, or will we cook by hand to truly connect with hearts and minds?”