Addressing FICCI this week, Prime Minister Narendra Modi read the riot act to the people in the room. India Inc, he said, is not creating enough jobs, is not paying good salaries, is not innovating, and is not taking advantage of the trade agreements the government has graciously signed. And all this after the government did industry the favour of cutting taxes! It was an unusual speech: A head of government blaming the private sector for outcomes that, in a market economy, are shaped mostly by the policies of the government.Government data provides the evidence to contradict the “conclusions” the government has provided the PM to present to the public.AdvertisementAlso Read | Surjit Bhalla writes: BJP is winning the elections but losing the economyStart with jobs of the kind industry provides — salaried jobs. In 2004-05 India had 67.9 million salaried workers. In 2011-12 there were 85.2 million salaried jobs, and in 2025, 147.6 million (all data from NSS-PLFS surveys). During the much-celebrated growth, not jobs, boom of 2004-11, salaried jobs grew by 2.5 million a year. Since 2011, the years in which industry has supposedly failed the nation, they have grown by 4.6 million a year, nearly twice as fast. Salaried jobs are now a quarter of all jobs, against a sixth in 2004. No previous period in India’s history comes even close to this record of salaried jobs creation. Total employment rose by a record 20 million a year between 2019-20 and 2024, mostly outside agriculture.The record for women’s jobs is even more striking. Women held 13.1 million salaried jobs in 2004-05 and 16.7 million in 2011-12. By 2025 they held 38.9 million. The number has more than doubled since 2011, growing by 1.6 million a year against half a million a year in 2004-11. Nearly one in five working women now draws a regular salary. If that is a failure to create jobs, one would like to know what success looks like. PM’s advisers and speech-writers, please note.Salaries. Here the PM has a point, but not the one he made. The average real salary, at 2024 prices, rose from Rs 18,442 a month in 2004-05 to Rs 23,637 in 2011-12, 3.5 per cent a year. Since then it has fallen slightly, by 0.4 per cent a year, to Rs 22,314 in 2025. The salary of a graduate fell from Rs 41,782 to Rs 35,046. Is this greed? No — it is economics 101. The number of employed graduates rose from 42 million in 2011-12 to 97 million in 2025. When the supply of anything more than doubles in 13 years, its price does not rise. Across developing countries, real wages grew 2.5 per cent a year in 2000-11 and 0.7 per cent a year after 2019 (ILO data). Since 2019, real wages have fallen in Indonesia (0.7 per cent a year), Egypt (0.8) and Bangladesh (2.5), and barely moved in Thailand (0.3). India, at 0.7, is in the middle of the pack. China does not publish its labour force survey results.AdvertisementAnd the workers at the bottom have done well. The daily wage of casual labourers, the poorest workers in India, has risen 3.4 per cent a year in real terms since 2011. A salaried worker earned 4.4 times a casual worker in 1999-2000, reduced to 2.4 times in 2024. That is a large fall in inequality, not stagnation. Asking firms to pay above the market rate is asking them to hire fewer people. Is that what the government wants?Taxes. India’s corporate tax cut of September 2019, from 30 to 22 per cent, was not a favour. It was a correction of one of the highest tax burdens in the developing world. Over 2019-24, general government tax revenue (excluding social security contributions) averaged 17.3 per cent of GDP in India. In China it was 14.3 per cent, in Vietnam 13.2 and in Indonesia 9.7. India, a much poorer country, taxes more than all of them. Allowing for income, India taxes 3.3 points of GDP more than expected; every major East Asian economy taxes less. The East Asian miracle was built on low taxes, not on lectures to industry.Trade deals and innovation. This complaint is a bit rich. Trade agreements open foreign markets to our firms; they do little for a firm whose inputs are taxed and rationed at home. Since 2018, budget after budget has raised import tariffs, and quality control orders (often dictated by members of the FICCI audience) now cover hundreds of products, from polyester fibre to footwear. Their effect is to keep out cheaper imported inputs and to protect the domestic suppliers of those inputs. Add the non-tariff barriers and an ultra-regressive 2015 model investment treaty, and it is easy to see why foreign investors are cautious (net FDI fell to under half a billion dollars in 2024-25). Firms innovate when they have to compete. A firm protected by tariffs and QCOs has every incentive to lobby, and none to innovate. The sad reality is that industry asks for protection, and the government obliges.Who makes policy? Industrialists do not write the customs tariff or the QCOs. The government does. If the policies are bad, and many are, the fault lies with those who advocate and implement them. Blaming firms for responding rationally to the incentives the government itself has created is the same as the age-old Indian saying: Ulta chor kotwal ko daante (the thief scolds the policeman).you may likeExhortation is not policy. Individuals and firms respond to incentives, to prices, taxes, tariffs and regulations, not to speeches. They hire when hiring pays and invest when investment pays. When they do not, the question for the government is not what is wrong with them, but what is wrong with its policies.The PM has rightly earned credit for a renewed push towards openness and for concluding the trade agreements with Britain and the EU. The best way to honour that vision is not to lecture FICCI. It is to overrule the babus who undermine reform, scrap the QCOs, cut tariffs, and let competition prevail. India Inc will respond to incentives. Just like the government.Bhalla is chairperson of the Technical Expert Group for the first official Household Income Survey of India. Views are personal