In the wake of the Central Government informing the Delhi High Court that it plans to “remove” a century-old mosque on the premises of Krishi Bhawan under the Central Vista redevelopment project, a fresh petition filed before the HC by a worshipper asks whether the Centre “can itself circumvent the rule of law merely because compliance…is inconvenient to its developmental plans.”Last month, in October, the Centre, responding to a different petition by the mosque committee, had admitted for the first time that it plans to “remove” the Qadeemi Masjid situated in the open court in Krishi Bhawan. Further, the Centre said that retaining the structure within the office complex is “impermissible and incompatible with the secular character of Government property”.The caretaking committee of the Waqf-notified Qadeemi Masjid had moved the court in September, apprehending demolition. The apprehension arose after a tender was floated by the Central Public Works Department (CPWD), under the Union Ministry of Housing and Urban Affairs (MoHUA), on January 19 for construction of Common Central Secretariat (CCS) buildings 4 and 5 at the site of Krishi Bhawan and Shastri Bhawan.Plea flags Centre’s ‘4 indispensable hurdles’A fresh and separate plea, moved by one Mohd Yasir on November 18, claiming to be a regular worshipper at the mosque and represented by advocate M Sufian Siddiqui, has flagged that a registered agreement, executed between the government and the predecessor of the Delhi Waqf Board, namely Sunni Majlis-e-Aukaf, in 1945, poses four “indispensable hurdles” that the government must cross before the purported removal of the mosque.The petitioner-worshipper has emphasised in the plea that, to remove the mosque, the Centre must first establish its legal right to do so, in light of the 1945 registered agreement, on which the Centre has remained silent, according to the petitioner. The 1945 agreement had detailed how the mosque should be used and controlled by the Waqf predecessor body. The agreement had also stipulated, as a condition, that it would be lawful for the government to enter and take back possession of the masjid, that is, the government’s right of re-entry, if there was any breach or default in the performance of the agreement’s clauses.Mohd Yasir’s plea contends that, in the backdrop of this 1945 agreement, the government has to first establish that there was a breach of the agreement, then invoke the clause that allows the government to re-enter, then lawfully determine the agreement, and finally, recover possession through due process of law by instituting appropriate civil proceedings through a civil suit.“Even lawful recovery of possession does not, by itself, authorise demolition of the Mosque”, the plea further notes, while asserting, “public purpose may explain the necessity asserted by the Union; it cannot substitute for the legal authority required to accomplish that purpose.”Story continues below this ad‘Secularism not a weapon to extinguish places of worship’Further, contesting the Centre’s position that the existence of the mosque is “incompatible” with the secular character of government premises, the plea points out that “secularism is a constitutional restraint upon the State, not a weapon in its hands to extinguish places of worship merely because it stands on Government-controlled land.”Taken up briefly for hearing on Friday, Justice Anish Dayal orally directed the Delhi Waqf Board, which is also a party to the plea and has been accused by the petitioner of abdicating its statutory duties by not taking the necessary steps to protect the mosque, to obtain instructions by the next date of hearing on November 23.Justice Dayal will now hear two pleas concerning the mosque on November 23.