In Elsinore, a Radiant Andrew Scott Finds Life in a Play About Death

Wait 5 sec.

Andrew Scott as Ian Charleson in Elsinore —Courtesy of Focus FeaturesContracting HIV is no longer a death sentence. But before the current medications and treatments emerged, the AIDS crisis of the 1980s and 1990s touched almost everyone, gay or straight, whether you wanted to admit it or not. Friends of friends, acquaintances or associates who brightened your day, or, worst of all, a loved one: people you cherished could wither and disappear in practically a heartbeat. The performing arts were hit especially hard, and there’s no way to reckon with the unfulfilled potential of the many gifted individuals who died prematurely.If you’d forgotten what it was like to live with the specter of AIDS, or if you weren’t alive at the time, Simon Stone’s biographical drama Elsinore—in which Andrew Scott stars as actor Ian Charleson, who landed the role of a lifetime just as he was becoming seriously ill with AIDS—brings back the mood of the time, not in a maudlin way but a bittersweet one. The Scottish-born Charleson had become famous for his starring role in 1981’s Chariots of Fire, a film millions saw and, not long after it won a slew of Oscars, promptly forgot. As Elsinore opens, circa 1989, we see Scott as Charleson looking listless in his nicely appointed London flat. The roles haven’t been pouring in, and when his agent reminds him of his Chariots success, he grumbles, “All they remember is the theme music.”Then Charleson gets news that may as well be a gift from the gods. While playing Hamlet in a 1989 National Theatre production, Daniel Day-Lewis had walked off the stage abruptly, never to return. The play’s director, Richard Eyre (played by Johnny Flynn, in a performance of such warmth it feels lit from within), wants Charleson to take over the role. The job is everything he’d longed for. But just as he’s beginning to feel that his career could once again soar, he notices a small lesion on his temple, a marker of the illness that so many of his friends and colleagues—among them filmmaker and gay rights activist Derek Jarman, played by David Dawson—are already fighting.Scott and Coleman in Elsinore —Courtesy of Focus FeaturesHow Charleson perseveres in making the role of Hamlet his own—often despite the protestations of the AIDS specialist who’s treating him, Olivia Colman’s Margaret Johnson—is Elsinore’s elegiac triumph. The script, by Stephen Beresford (writer of the 2014 historical comedy Pride), never veers into mawkishness, nor does it downplay the stark reality of Charleson’s debilitations. And while it’s understandable that he’d want to hide his illness for professional reasons, even from his fellow Hamlet performers, Charleson’s secretiveness rankles some of his friends, including Jarman, who believes transparency about AIDS is the only way to gain the public attention.Scott’s performance is both elegant and feral, and it cuts to the heart of some of the era’s political complexities. Charleson was 40 when he played Hamlet; he pulled off a highly acclaimed six-week run and died eight weeks later. Scott plays Charleson with a grand hedgehog spikiness. If he has the energy to fight for only one cause, he’ll choose the grandeur of art. Both down to earth and crabbily noble, he won’t let anyone tell him what to do, not even Colman’s Johnson. “Nobody ever leaves Hamlet thinking, ‘Gosh, what a short night of light entertainment!’” she tells Charleson, and she’s not wrong about the demands of the role.The beautiful paradox of Elsinore is that a play about death should be the thing that fills an actor’s last days with so much life.  We can see Charleson outrunning his fate for as long as he can. He grouses at his friends, and at Johnson—basically at anyone who’d dare tell him he’s doing it all wrong. Like the character he’s playing onstage, Scott’s Charleson is a stubborn, unruly prince, radiant with life even as it’s being drained out of him. It’s in his most unlikable moments that we love him the most.