In her memoir, Sonia Gandhi shows her idea of India comes from a family

Wait 5 sec.

Even her idea of India, pluralistic and inclusive, comes from family rather than direct emotional experience. One of the most moving parts of the book is when she accompanies her mother-in-law to Anand Bhavan, the historic family home in Allahabad. Here Sonia Gandhi learns of the intermixing of her family history, the Congress’ history, and India’s history. They are not three separate stories; they are oneAI Narration Listen 00:000.5x0.75x1x1.25x1.5x2x5 min readNov 20, 2026 05:40 PM IST First published on: Nov 20, 2026 at 05:40 PM ISTRather than “Belonging”, Sonia Gandhi’s memoir should have been titled “Duty”. In particular: Duty to family. That is the theme of the book. Her life has been defined by a single choice: To fall in love with a man she saw in a restaurant in 1965. That choice set in motion a series of filial duties – moving to India (1968), becoming an Indian citizen (1983), becoming Congress President (1998) and being the principal vote-gatherer for the UPA government (2004 to 2014). None of this was what she wanted, but fate – specifically the deaths of Sanjay, Indira, and her beloved Rajiv Gandhi – propelled her into fulfilling her duty rather than living her life.It’s a powerful story. It’s also elegantly told. No, the book is not meant to help the Congress win the coming UP elections. And the occasional barbs at a Pranab Mukherjee or a Maneka Gandhi are hardly the point. Sonia Gandhi comes across as authentic and classy, refusing to be trapped in either pandering to the immediate moment or to settle ancient grudges.AdvertisementIf she goes easy on her enemies, Sonia Gandhi goes even easier on her husband, mother-in-law, and son. Despite having the largest majority any prime minister enjoyed in 1984, Rajiv squandered it. Perhaps, just perhaps, the fault could lie in the obvious inexperience of a pilot who had wanted little to do with politics until three years before becoming prime minister? But Sonia Gandhi will have none of it. Rajiv — “Abhimanyu” in her telling — is encircled by conspirators and enemies. He is unfairly attacked because Rajiv — the son and grandson of prime ministers — is an outsider trying to change the system and the entrenched elites won’t have it. Indira Gandhi and, especially Rahul Gandhi, are similarly exempt from anything resembling critical analysis. As she herself says early in the book, “To Italian mothers a son was no different from what he was to a traditional Indian mother: He came first, full stop.”This blind spot is a feature not a bug: Sonia Gandhi is loyal, first and foremost, to her family. Even her idea of India, pluralistic and inclusive, comes from family rather than direct emotional experience. One of the most moving parts of the book is when she accompanies her mother-in-law to Anand Bhavan, the historic family home in Allahabad. Here Sonia Gandhi learns of the intermixing of her family history, the Congress’ history, and India’s history. They are not three separate stories; they are one.Also Read | Sonia Gandhi’s story raises a question: Can a saas ever become ‘Ma’?This is not just semantics; it matters. For instance, Sonia Gandhi does not see the Congress party she led for 22 years as a public institution, meant to mirror the aspirations of a changing country. She sees it as a family legacy, built by her husband and his family, and bequeathed to her. When she takes over the Congress in 1998, it is not because her country needs her help. It is because her family legacy needs to be kept alive. When she fights to prevent Rajiv Gandhi from becoming prime minister, it’s not because the overambitious Pranab Mukherjee is more qualified (which he surely was). It is because Rajiv in power will hurt her marriage and children.AdvertisementOne of the problems the Congress faces today is that the India that once brought them to power has since changed beyond recognition, and the party has not adapted. Reading Belonging, we can see why. Except for a small reference towards the end, the India of her family’s (and therefore her) imagination remains the India until the 1990s. There is little scope for the new India with its newer problems — of digital aspirations, youth employment, higher education, and rapid urbanisation. The Congress’ longest-serving president never asks: Has India changed beyond the imagination of my husband and mother-in-law? How do we restructure the Congress to cater to this change?Sonia Gandhi has endured because she is that rarest of politicians — she is not in it for herself. It is manifest in her most famous decision — to not become prime minister in 2004. The clarity with which she saw the BJP-RSS as the enemies to the pluralistic vision of her Nehru-Gandhi family also means that she will be remembered as the unifying figure, like Bahadur Shah Zafar, around which anti-BJP forces coalesced.you may likeBut hers is a private, traditional sort of selflessness, at odds with the modern patriotism required for a country in the 21st century. Her primary duty is not to other Indians (the very basis of modern citizenship); rather it is to other family members. She sees the Congress as a precious inheritance rather than a living reality. It has led to her single biggest failure – to use the Congress’ time in national power from 2004 to 2014 to revitalise and modernise the party organisation. As a result, though she took over the Congress to protect her family legacy from the rising BJP, her enduring legacy will be to enable the rise of Narendra Modi.Sonia Gandhi has done her duty. But in investing in her for this long, have the Congress and its allies done theirs? In that Greek restaurant in Cambridge in 1965, Rajiv Gandhi clearly chose well. But in all those decades since, did we?Sitapati is an academic and author of books on PV Narasimha Rao and the BJP before Modi