An Awful Day at Work … In a Fantasy Epic

Wait 5 sec.

The following article contains spoilers through Season 3, Episode 3 of House of the Dragon.Halfway through the latest episode of House of the Dragon, the freshly crowned Rhaenyra Targaryen concedes that being a leader is already taking a heavy toll on her. “I am awash in dilemmas,” the queen (played by Emma D’Arcy) sighs to one of her many supporters. Ascending the Iron Throne has, it’s true, made her life far worse than when she was vying for it against her half brother Aegon (Tom Glynn-Carney): Her new home in King’s Landing is crawling with rats—literally and figuratively. The treasury has been depleted by a civil war, which means no lavish coronation to inspire the smallfolk. Her allies keep pestering her, either for prizes or for proof that she has exacted ruthless revenge on their enemies.This all appears to be mental torture for Rhaenyra. As a Targaryen—a member of the incestuous, dragon-riding dynasty—she must reject the family motto, “Fire and blood,” to deal with practical matters as diplomatically as possible. But Rhaenyra’s discomfort has provided an invigorating change of pace and tone for a typical fantasy epic. House of the Dragon, HBO’s prequel series to Game of Thrones, has relied on the spectacle of fiery battles and CGI dragons to make up for thinly written characters and convoluted plotting throughout the show. By homing in on the psychological torment of winning the crown, the show offers a surprising detour from familiar carnage—while suggesting that disappointment over a seemingly ideal position can be as crushing as a defeat on the battlefield.The author, George R. R. Martin, didn’t go into much detail about Rhaenyra’s mindset in Fire and Blood, the doorstop of a book on which House of the Dragon is based. When describing Rhaenyra’s actions during her period of triumph, Martin portrays her simply as a satisfied victor who “set about rewarding her friends and inflicting savage punishments on those who had served her half-brother.” The show wisely expands beyond the scant description while adding nuance to Rhaenyra’s most brutal moves. She hesitates before beheading Otto (Rhys Ifans), Aegon’s most trusted adviser who conspired against her, clearly doubting whether such violence will convince her subjects that she is a strong queen. When her uncle-husband, Daemon (Matt Smith), urges her to kill her youngest half brother so that there are no other claimants for the throne, she visits the child first to assess for herself whether he poses a threat. She chooses to keep him alive, a decision that serves her well later, when it turns out the boy isn’t who he says he is.[Read: House of the Dragon is cruel, messy, and fascinating]Rhaenyra’s tenure has been difficult, the show makes clear, because of how careful she wants to be—an unusual quality for any story set in Westeros. Queens have rarely been depicted as trying to create a more peaceful realm, let alone as figuring out how to rule without encouraging further, unnecessary violence: In Game of Thrones, both Cersei Lannister and Daenerys Targaryen went mad with power, setting King’s Landing aflame. The Iron Throne, made of melted-down swords, is understood to be a harsh seat, cutting those who sit in it and corrupting them over time. But Rhaenyra is different: She’s a woman raised to rule, not just occupy the throne. She wants to listen to the smallfolk and make peace with the wealthy. She seems to believe that she can tame her warmongering family without resorting to manipulation and trickery. Rhaenyra is, in other words, an idealist, a people pleaser discovering that for all the barriers she’d expected and prepared for—doubt over her capabilities as a woman, logistical problems related to her coronation—the pressure of choosing to be a compassionate queen is particularly gnarly.Perhaps the only one who can relate is Alicent (Olivia Cooke), Rhaenyra’s childhood best friend turned stepmother who also happens to be Otto’s daughter and Aegon’s mother. (House of the Dragon can get terribly confusing, given all of the incest.) Alicent had essentially ruled Westeros when her husband, Rhaenyra’s father, became too ill to do so. Since Season 1, Rhaenyra and Alicent’s complicated relationship, another change from Martin’s text, has been a highlight of House of the Dragon, and Episode 3 delivers an excellent scene of the pair discussing the troubles that come with leadership. Their exchange is rife with tension built from years of resentment and fear, not to mention the fact that Alicent is now Rhaenyra’s prisoner.When Alicent gives Rhaenyra advice, her guidance is cutting but honest: To be queen, she explains, Rhaenyra will have to shed her hopes of making as many people happy as possible, to become what she is not. “In truth, you may not rule and remain yourself,” Alicent says. “There are choices to be made, and you may on occasion have to turn your face away while people suffer and die. There is in you a door that must shut. You will do things that your heart will have recoiled from before you came to the throne.”[Read: The glaring flaw at the heart of House of the Dragon]Rhaenyra finds it tough to become more ruthless, making interactions with her subjects fascinatingly uneasy. To get to the Iron Throne, Rhaenyra has largely commanded others to fight in her stead, building support by emphasizing how deeply she’d been wronged by her family. Even when she takes the Red Keep, Daemon slices through Aegon’s forces while she sidesteps the violence.But on her first day of granting an audience with the smallfolk, her period arrives—a twisted, almost humorous reminder that she’ll have to acknowledge the blood on her hands. She had intended to appear confident before her people, to relate to them, but she ends up hiding a part of herself anyway, squirming on the Iron Throne as she listens to their pleas for help. When Rhaenyra gathers her advisers for a meeting, she attempts to quell her cramps by inconspicuously drinking tea, but becomes frustrated with all the squabbling. When one of them sycophantically defers an issue to her after she had just asked him for his opinion, she looks ready to feed him to her dragon. “Useless,” she calls him—a jab that brought refreshing levity to an otherwise grim show.This version of House of the Dragon, with its rare glimpse of the trials of a well-intentioned queen, won’t last. Even those who haven’t read Martin’s books know that House of the Dragon is a tragedy: The dragons eventually die; the Targaryen empire crumbles; the wheel keeps turning. The pleasure of a fantasy epic, however, comes in part from the opportunity to venture inside castle walls. To probe the mind of a queen on a singularly awful day on the job, then, is not just an uncommon experience; it’s exhilarating.