T.N. govt. gave no advance notice on Justice Kurian panel’s dissolution: member - The HinduPublished - November 22, 2026 01:06 am IST - ChennaiRetired IAS officer K. Ashok Vardhan Shetty, a member of the committee on Union-State relations, has stated that neither he nor the panel’s head, Justice Kurian Joseph, was informed prior to its dissolution. In a detailed interview with The Hindu 360 YouTube channel, Mr. Shetty revealed that the government had initially cleared the panel to continue its work.“I think it was on May 4 when a fellow member, M. Naganathan, resigned. Because of this, we were forced to seek clarity from the government on the continuation of the committee. I spoke to the Chief Secretary asking whether we should continue, and also requested him to consider not appointing a replacement for Dr. Naganathan if we were to carry on. About a week later, the then-Public Secretary, Reeta Harish Thakkar, called me and said, ‘Sir, the government has said you can continue,’ adding that no new member would be appointed. So, we continued. While all other committees constituted during the previous regime were contacted and asked to step down, nothing of that sort happened to us. Suddenly, one day, they dissolved it,” Mr. Shetty recounted.The mandate of the dissolved panel has now been handed over to the State Law Commission. Addressing the Government Order (G.O.) that cited the Kurian Committee’s status as a non-statutory body, Mr. Shetty pointed out that the Law Commission holds the exact same legal standing. “The Law Commission was created by a 1994 G.O., and ever since, it has been reconstituted through similar orders. So, the Law Commission is also an executive body — just like we were, and just like the Punchhi and Sarkaria Commissions,” he said.He also questioned the feasibility of the transfer, noting that the State Law Commission has never examined Union-State ties in its over three decades of existence. “In the last 32 years, the State Law Commission has never gone into this issue. They already have seven or eight terms of reference. Looking into Union-State relations alone takes us two years. When the Law Commission’s tenure itself is three years, how can they dedicate two years to this single subject? Furthermore, never in history has Part One of a report been written by one committee and Part Two by another,” he said.Mr. Shetty added that the pending work falls outside the Law Commission’s core competence. “Unlike Part One, which dealt largely with legal and constitutional matters, Part Two focused heavily on policy issues — such as climate change, local governance, arts, history, science, culture, and transportation. None of these fall within the purview of the Law Commission.”Had the panel been permitted to continue, it would have submitted the second and final part of its report by May 31, he said.Published - November 22, 2026 01:06 am ISTSign in to unlock member-only benefits!Access 10 free stories every monthSave stories to read laterAccess to comment on every storySign-up/manage your newsletter subscriptions with a single clickGet notified by email for early access to discounts & offers on our products${ ind + 1 } ${ device }Last active - ${ la }