Last week, TDN published Bill Finley's investigation into several horses that had raced at Finger Lakes racetrack in New York and Mountaineer Park in West Virginia, before subsequently finding their way into the horse slaughter pipeline.The horses included Post Facto, who finished eighth in a $5,000 claimer on Oct. 27 of this year at Finger Lakes.Twelve days later, he wound up at the Southern Ohio Horse Ship Pen. The owner and operator of this holding pen, Brian Duggan, told Finley how some horses that come into his possession wind up being sent to slaughter.Another horse was Crystal Water (Curlin's Honor), who last raced at Mountaineer Park Nov. 4, finishing eighth of 10. Three days later, the 4-year-old filly was sent to the Smokey Lane auction in Ohio and purchased by Duggan.Smokey Lane is a family-run operation under the Smokey Lane Stables banner.Crystal Water, owned and trained by Moises Valdez, is entered to race at Mountaineer Park Nov. 24–a strange state of affairs, as Crystal Water was, at least recently, in the process of being bailed from Duggan's Southern Ohio Horse Ship Pen.Unlike the vast majority of tracks around the country, Mountaineer Park does not currently have a contractual anti-slaughter policy.“If you are found guilty of selling a horse to the slaughterhouse, then we would 1000% take your stalls, management will exclude you,” said Michael Bish, the track's director of racing. “We take that very seriously here.”However, no language is written into Mountaineer's 2026 stall app–the contract between the track and the trainer, and the document into which anti-slaughter policies are typically written.Online overnights and condition books from the track do not contain any such policies either.Anti-slaughter language, said Bish, will be inserted into the track's 2027 stall application.“I'm going to tell you right now, that's going to be the first order of business for me as far as next year, to get that written into the stall app,” said Bish.The track used to have an anti-slaughter policy.According to multiple trade industry publication stories from 2012, Mountaineer's policy stated at that time how owners and trainers allotted stalls “shall not directly or indirectly cause a horse to be put to slaughter,” a process that reportedly involved vetting third parties before horses are sold to them.When asked when that language had been removed, Bish wasn't sure, as he had entered the job in 2025, he said.West Virginia Racing Commission's executive director Joe Moore declined to discuss the status of Mountaineer's anti-slaughter policy.TDN called Moore Friday to discuss these policies at the state and track level. In a follow-up email, Moore shared the commission's anti-slaughter language.The commission can refuse to issue or renew a license to a permit holder who has “knowingly, or without conducting proper due diligence, sold a horse for slaughter, directly. 'Due diligence: as used in this subdivision, shall mean the care and prudence that a reasonable racing permit holder should exercise to avoid selling a horse to a person or persons who may cause a horse to be conveyed to slaughter,'” according to state's rules.Both over the phone and in a follow-up email, Moore declined to discuss Mountaineer's approach to stemming the track-to-slaughter pipeline.“Questions regarding any such house rule at Mountaineer Park need to be directed to track management,” wrote Moore, in an email.West Virginia is currently operating outside the jurisdiction of the Horseracing Integrity and Safety Act (HISA) through a court ruling.When asked about Crystal Water being entered to race at Mountaineer this Tuesday (after having been sold through Smokey Lane), Bish said the track will likely initiate the process to potentially exclude the horse's trainer, Valdez.“I've recommended to our stewards that we need to do something about this,” said Bish. “As far as I'm concerned, I'm going to put in the motion to management [to] exclude this guy,” said Bish.When asked about Finley's investigation more broadly, Bish said that the Smokey Lane auction is not a kill pen. “It has been vetted out by the state of West Virginia as a reputable horse auction,” said Bish.In Finley's investigation, however, Duggan, who attends the auction, describes the process by which he purchases Thoroughbreds and other horses and tries to sell them for a mark-up. But he admitted that the ones he can't sell, he sends for slaughter.“We buy and sell horses to sell them for a profit,” Duggan told Finley. “That's what we do. I mean, if they don't want to buy them, they don't have to. I mean, we buy ponies, we buy work horses, we'll buy anything.”When asked directly by the TDN if he would admit that horses that have come through his operation sometimes wound up in a slaughterhouse, Duggan's answer was simple. He said, “Yeah.”“There's only so many places to go with them,” Duggan told Finley, defending his acceptance of slaughter. “There's only so much you can do with them, so many people that can feed them. And if they don't feed them, they end up in very poor condition. In my opinion, I'd rather see one slaughtered than starve to death.”When asked about Duggan's comments in the story, Bish admitted that, with the meet set to conclude Dec. 9, this is a period in which many of the track's horses are vulnerable to similarly falling through the cracks.“You're going to have people just mass exit as [a] fire sale, you know, get rid of everything that's not going to pan out,” he said.“This is the end of the meet. You know, I've got people all over the place back there trying to dump horses because they don't want to feed them or sit on them all winter,” he said.The post Mountaineer Park Has No Contractual Anti-Slaughter Policy appeared first on TDN | Thoroughbred Daily News | Horse Racing News, Results and Video | Thoroughbred Breeding and Auctions.