Jerusalem Declaration on Antisemitism

Wait 5 sec.

Criticism: Whoops. Described figure is it:Sergio Luzzatto, who partially based his claims on Ariel Toaff. Remove source which doesn't mention Luzzatto or Nelson.← Previous revisionRevision as of 16:44, 22 November 2026 Line 93: Line 93: Israeli academic [[Gerald Steinberg]] and American historian [[Asaf Romirowsky]] said that the Jerusalem Declaration legitimizes increasing violence against Jews and their institutions by politicizing and attempting to undermine efforts to reach a consensus on antisemitism. The authors criticized the declaration for its extensive use of "[[weasel word]]s" like "on the face of it" and "in and of itself/themselves", which they said obscures the fact that arguments are often reinterpreted in different contexts and take on meaning beyond that of the words used to express them. The authors also claimed the declaration "marginalizes the core issues of antisemitism" by subordinating it to the fight against all other forms of discrimination.{{Cite web|first1=Gerald M. |last1=Steinberg|first2=Asaf |last2=Romirowsky|date=2021-04-04|title=The Jerusalem Declaration's Bogus Definition of Anti-Semitism|url=https://nationalinterest.org/blog/middle-east-watch/jerusalem-declaration%E2%80%99s-bogus-definition-anti-semitism-181960|access-date=2021-07-22|website=The National Interest|language=en}} [[David Hirsh]], a lecturer in [[sociology]] at [[Goldsmiths, University of London|Goldsmiths University of London]], criticized the declaration on the grounds that it "does not help the fight against antisemitism", and has a blind spot for antisemitism that originates on the political left. The JDA, he wrote, is flawed because it "asks institutions to affirm that BDS ... singling out Israel as uniquely colonial or apartheid, and saying that Israel has no right to exist, are not, 'in and of themselves', antisemitic", when, according to Hirsh, those things "are at the heart of contemporary left antisemitism".{{Cite news|last=Hirsch|first=David|date=2021-04-01|title=The Jerusalem Declaration defines the 'community of the good', not antisemitism|work=[[The Jewish Chronicle]]|url=https://www.thejc.com/opinion/the-jerusalem-declaration-defines-the-community-of-the-good-lbgbxwt6|access-date=2021-07-12}} Israeli academic [[Gerald Steinberg]] and American historian [[Asaf Romirowsky]] said that the Jerusalem Declaration legitimizes increasing violence against Jews and their institutions by politicizing and attempting to undermine efforts to reach a consensus on antisemitism. The authors criticized the declaration for its extensive use of "[[weasel word]]s" like "on the face of it" and "in and of itself/themselves", which they said obscures the fact that arguments are often reinterpreted in different contexts and take on meaning beyond that of the words used to express them. The authors also claimed the declaration "marginalizes the core issues of antisemitism" by subordinating it to the fight against all other forms of discrimination.{{Cite web|first1=Gerald M. |last1=Steinberg|first2=Asaf |last2=Romirowsky|date=2021-04-04|title=The Jerusalem Declaration's Bogus Definition of Anti-Semitism|url=https://nationalinterest.org/blog/middle-east-watch/jerusalem-declaration%E2%80%99s-bogus-definition-anti-semitism-181960|access-date=2021-07-22|website=The National Interest|language=en}} [[David Hirsh]], a lecturer in [[sociology]] at [[Goldsmiths, University of London|Goldsmiths University of London]], criticized the declaration on the grounds that it "does not help the fight against antisemitism", and has a blind spot for antisemitism that originates on the political left. The JDA, he wrote, is flawed because it "asks institutions to affirm that BDS ... singling out Israel as uniquely colonial or apartheid, and saying that Israel has no right to exist, are not, 'in and of themselves', antisemitic", when, according to Hirsh, those things "are at the heart of contemporary left antisemitism".{{Cite news|last=Hirsch|first=David|date=2021-04-01|title=The Jerusalem Declaration defines the 'community of the good', not antisemitism|work=[[The Jewish Chronicle]]|url=https://www.thejc.com/opinion/the-jerusalem-declaration-defines-the-community-of-the-good-lbgbxwt6|access-date=2021-07-12}} [[Cary Nelson]], former president of the [[American Association of University Professors]], criticized the Jerusalem Declaration on the basis that it seeks to accommodate manifestations of "[[new antisemitism]]" rather than challenge them. Nelson said the declaration's preamble is dismissive of the ways that antisemitism has stood apart from other forms of racism historically and how that history has shaped Jewish identity. He also said it makes generalizations about antisemitism that do not apply under many circumstances, like claiming that the hallmark of classic antisemitism is "the idea that Jews are linked to the forces of evil". He also said that many amongst the signers of the declaration are "anti-Zionists who cross a line into antisemitism", including [[Ariel Toaff]], a historian at the University of Connecticut who, Nelson alleged, believed that medieval [[blood libel]] was true.{{Cite web|last1=Sanders|first1=Gabriel|date=February 16, 2007|title=Scholar Pulls Book Revisiting Blood Libel|url=https://forward.com/news/10085/blood-libel-scholar-pulls-book-pledges-funds-to-a/|access-date=2021-07-22|website=The Forward|language=en-US}}{{Cite web|title=Accommodating the New Antisemitism: a Critique of 'The Jerusalem Declaration' |first=Cary |last=Nelson |url=https://fathomjournal.org/fathom-long-read-accommodating-the-new-antisemitism-a-critique-of-the-jerusalem-declaration/|access-date=2021-07-22|website=Fathom}} [[Joshua Muravchik]], a professor at the [[Institute of World Politics]], criticized it for seeking to contextualize antisemitism within a broader fight against all other forms of discrimination because that framing ignores that Jews are often discriminated against by other minorities. He said that by claiming "that the struggle against anti-Semitism is inseparable from similar struggles, the JDA seems to be addressing the wrong audience; much of the anti-Semitism that plagues Jews arises from non-majority groups".{{Cite web|title=The Emerging War over Anti-Semitism |url=https://mosaicmagazine.com/essay/politics-current-affairs/2021/07/the-emerging-war-over-anti-semitism/|access-date=2021-08-05|website=Mosaic}} [[Cary Nelson]], former president of the [[American Association of University Professors]], criticized the Jerusalem Declaration on the basis that it seeks to accommodate manifestations of "[[new antisemitism]]" rather than challenge them. Nelson said the declaration's preamble is dismissive of the ways that antisemitism has stood apart from other forms of racism historically and how that history has shaped Jewish identity. He also said it makes generalizations about antisemitism that do not apply under many circumstances, like claiming that the hallmark of classic antisemitism is "the idea that Jews are linked to the forces of evil". He also said that many amongst the signers of the declaration are "anti-Zionists who cross a line into antisemitism", including {{ill|Sergio Luzzatto|it}}, a historian at the University of Connecticut who, Nelson alleged, believed that medieval [[blood libel]] was true.{{Cite web|title=Accommodating the New Antisemitism: a Critique of 'The Jerusalem Declaration' |first=Cary |last=Nelson |url=https://fathomjournal.org/fathom-long-read-accommodating-the-new-antisemitism-a-critique-of-the-jerusalem-declaration/|access-date=2021-07-22|website=Fathom}} [[Joshua Muravchik]], a professor at the [[Institute of World Politics]], criticized it for seeking to contextualize antisemitism within a broader fight against all other forms of discrimination because that framing ignores that Jews are often discriminated against by other minorities. He said that by claiming "that the struggle against anti-Semitism is inseparable from similar struggles, the JDA seems to be addressing the wrong audience; much of the anti-Semitism that plagues Jews arises from non-majority groups".{{Cite web|title=The Emerging War over Anti-Semitism |url=https://mosaicmagazine.com/essay/politics-current-affairs/2021/07/the-emerging-war-over-anti-semitism/|access-date=2021-08-05|website=Mosaic}} === Response to criticism === === Response to criticism ===