6 min readNov 22, 2026 07:04 AM IST First published on: Nov 22, 2026 at 06:50 AM ISTWhen you have written a political column for nearly half a century as I have, you get used to being treated as a sort of seer with wondrous abilities to see things that others cannot. Strangers at airports and restaurants ask me questions like if I think that Narendra Modi’s popularity has waned, or if I see him becoming prime minister for a fourth term. Lately, since Sonia Gandhi’s memoir became a massive bestseller within days of being published, the questions have mostly been about the Dynasty and its heir.Do I think that Rahul Gandhi has become a real leader now? Do I think that he will carry forward his family legacy and become prime minister? An inevitable question since three of India’s prime ministers came from his family. And his Mummy was de facto prime minister for a decade. My way of getting out of straight answers is to ask a question or two of my own — so I ask if they voted for Modi in the last general election and if they have now changed their mind about him.AdvertisementIt is interesting that many of my questioners had voted for Modi in the past three general elections but do not wish to in the future. This is mostly because a certain disenchantment has set in and because they see that corruption has increased enormously, and Modi seems unable to stop it. But when I ask if they would go back to voting for the Dynasty, they prevaricate. They are not sure that they would like to see Rahul Gandhi as prime minister. So, do I think he is now on his way to becoming prime minister after the next general election? I am not sure.Last week he travelled to the United States and declared grandly that India is sitting on an ‘economic disaster’. Usually on his travels abroad he concentrates on trying to convince Indians of the diaspora that ‘Indian democracy is dead’. This time, he said unemployment is a huge problem; manufacturing has not taken off; and there is distress in the farm sector; and small and medium businesses are unhappy.When he talked about the destruction of the ‘economic architecture built by Congress over decades’, he totally lost me. Having lived through those bleak, socialist decades when Rahul’s family ruled India, I remembered the shabby goods that were ‘made in India’ and how anyone who could afford to bought foreign goods from smugglers or smuggled them in whenever they could. Things began to change only when India was led by a prime minister whose last name was not Gandhi. And who dismantled the license raj that had strangled the economy at a time when countries in Southeast Asia were soaring ahead, while China was on its way to becoming the economic superpower it is today.AdvertisementIt is to Narendra Modi’s credit that he did not introduce the BJP version of Nehruvian socialism — christened Gandhian socialism to disguise the truth that it was the same old idea. Is Rahul Gandhi a Nehruvian socialist or a socialist of any kind? Would he take us back to the kind of economic ideas that his grandmother espoused? Sonia Gandhi, in her book, credits her husband with ‘liberalising’ the Indian economy, but this is not true. Ask our own ‘tech-bros’ in Bangalore about this, and they will tell you how importing a computer into India took more than a year and many trips to Delhi. It was P V Narasimha Rao who showed the courage to chuck Nehruvian socialism out of the window, and despite doing this, he called himself a socialist till his dying day.you may likeThe sad truth is that Modi has not continued with the reforms that began with the end of the license raj, so to this day doing business in India is a nightmare. Except for a handful of tycoons at the top. Last week, the prime minister berated a gathering of businessmen for not paying their workers better and for not investing more. Instead, he needs to ask himself why private investment has not yet picked up. Rahul Gandhi seems to believe it is because the Congress party is no longer in power, and that’s a belief he needs to reexamine swiftly.So then to come back to the question I am being asked a lot these days: is Rahul Gandhi being taken more seriously? Is he the only real challenger to Modi? Judging by the hysteria his visits abroad are causing within the ranks of the BJP, it certainly seems this is true. As usual, when he says something on foreign soil, he was charged last week with being anti-India by BJP spokespersons and some of them deliberately distorted his name and mocked him about his mother’s Italian origins. It does not really matter if I think he has reinvented himself as a leader with maturity and gravitas. What matters is that the BJP thinks he has.Meanwhile, Rahul Gandhi needs to do much more to rebuild the broken base of the party he inherited, as a family heirloom, if he wants to be the main opposition player when the next general election comes around. And he needs to appoint a shadow cabinet that would give us a glimpse of what kind of politician he is. One who believes in courtiers or one who believes in strong ministers.