Why Risk Ratio Is Preferred, What is Modified Poisson, and Why Do We Even Care About Standard Error?

Wait 5 sec.

[This article was first published on r on Everyday Is A School Day, and kindly contributed to R-bloggers]. (You can report issue about the content on this page here)Want to share your content on R-bloggers? click here if you have a blog, or here if you don't.Learnt about modified Poisson for the first time. Simulated RR vs OR, log-binomial and robust SE, then sprinkled in repeated measures. Turns out a 95% CI can be too narrow (confidently wrong) or too wide (overly cautious)! Still learning, but pretty convinced now Motivations I was working on a project recently and learnt a few things as we were going along and want to look into it a bit more with simulation to see for myself. These might sound like some random topics, but they’re all kind of tied together, at least in my mind they are. I’ve not heard of modified poisson before and what a great way to get from incompetent incompetence to at least competent incompetence. Knowing what we don’t know is definitely better than not knowing what we don’t know (MNAR problem). Well let’s explore together and see for ourselves, will this be our next go-to model along with robust sandwich standard error? Oh, let’s also sprinkle a little bit of repeatd measure (some clustering) to beef up that SE to see an even better effect with this robust sandwich standard error. Let’s go! Thought Process But, how are we going to do this? Let’s go through the bare basics of the interpretation, let’s say we have binary outcome. A heuristic is to use logistic regression model with logit as link function. It’s a great model, but exponentiating on the coefficient of exposure turns it into odds ratio instead of risk ratio (RR). So, let's talk a bit about why risk ratio may be a bit easier to understand than odds ratio. After this we’ll look and see how can we simulate using baseline rate and RR. And use this simulated data to check on our regular poisson regression, log binomial regression, logistic regression with logit link, then poisson regression w robust SE (aka modified poisson). We’ll look at their wideness of 95%CI. Then, to sprinkle a little bit of sweetness on top, we’ll add on repeated measure, look at SE of all these models. Top it up with, g-computation using logistic regression & bootstrap based on subject and see how that matches up with modified poisson.Objectives: Why Risk Ratio?Simulate Baseline Rate and RRComparisonPoisson RegressionLog Binomial RegressionLogistic Regression with Logit LinkPoisson Regression with Robust Standard Error (Modified Poisson)High Event RatesHigh RRVery High RRRepeat MeasuresRR Without Modified Poisson with LR G-computation with subject level bootstrapReplicates of Our 4 ScenariosOpportunities For ImprovementLessons LearntWhy Risk Ratio? Risk Ratio is easier to understand because it’s basically risk of event in exposed group divided by risk of event in unexposed group (p1/p0). So, if we have an RR of 0.6, we’re saying the exposed group has 40% less risk of event than the unexposed group. If we have an RR of 1.5, we’re saying the exposed group has 50% more risk of event than the unexposed group. That’s much more intuitive than the odds ratio, which only approximates RR when the outcome is rare (roughly