/u/Alternative_Design_4 on My neighbor asked if I had any "extra" furniture after seeing I'd just moved in

Wait 5 sec.

She doesn't need any of your theoretical "extra" stuff. She's looking to sell your stuff for her own profit. No one breaks a coffee table, loses a bed frame, etc., all miraculously on the day you move in! She's a leech, or she's a drug addict.